Answer the following questions in about 150 words each :
“If religion were a subject of reason alone, it would have lacked an experiential account.” Do you agree with this statement ? Give reasons in support of your answer.
10 marks · answer in 150 words · directive: Do you agree; Give reasons
The core of a good answer
Largely yes: a religion built on reason alone, such as deism or Kant's moral religion, gives arguments about God but leaves out the lived encounter with the holy that believers report (Schleiermacher, Otto, James); yet experience needs reason to interpret and test it, so a full account of religion needs both.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
The directive asks for your position and reasons. Explain what religion within reason alone looks like, show what it misses, then show the role reason still plays, and conclude.
Answer outline
Introduction
Rational religion seeks to justify belief by argument (natural theology, deism) or by morality, as in Kant's Religion within the Bounds of Bare Reason (1793). The statement claims such religion misses the experiential side.
Reasons for agreeing
- Schleiermacher, On Religion (1799), located religion in feeling and intuition of the infinite, later the feeling of absolute dependence, not in metaphysics or morals.
- Rudolf Otto, The Idea of the Holy (1917): the numinous, mysterium tremendum et fascinans, is non rational and cannot be reduced to concepts.
- William James (1902): personal experience, not theology, is the primary stuff of religion.
Reasons for qualifying
- Experience needs interpretation; reason distinguishes genuine experience from delusion (tests of coherence and moral fruits).
- Richard Swinburne's principle of credulity holds that what seems to one to be present actually is present unless some defeater is operative, a rational use of experience.
- Purely experiential religion risks fanaticism.
Conclusion
The statement is right that reason alone yields at best a philosopher's God; religion as lived needs experience, while reason keeps that experience honest.
Examples and data to cite
- Otto, Das Heilige (The Idea of the Holy), 1917.
- Kant, Religion within the Bounds of Bare Reason, 1793.
Facts to remember
- Schleiermacher: religion as the feeling of absolute dependence.
- Otto: the numinous as mysterium tremendum et fascinans.
- Swinburne's principle of credulity: what seems to be present probably is, unless a defeater is operative.