Pratidin
2026 · Philosophy Optional Paper II · 20 marksMainsQuestion 6a

In what sense does St. Augustine’s identification of all evil as either sin or as the punishment of sin succeed or fail in providing a coherent account of both moral and natural evil ? Evaluate.

20 marks · directive: Evaluate

Answer

The core of a good answer

Augustine's formula succeeds for moral evil, which it traces to the free misuse of the will by creatures, and it gives a unified picture in which evil is a privation of good and suffering is just penalty; it fails for natural evil, because it ties earthquakes, disease and animal pain to a historical fall although natural disasters and disease existed before humans, makes innocent suffering 'punishment', and leaves unexplained how perfect creatures could fall.

An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work

What the question asks

Evaluate asks for a judgement on coherence. Explain the theory (privation, free will, fall, punishment), show where it succeeds, then the main objections, especially on natural evil, and conclude.

Answer outline

Introduction

Augustine of Hippo (354 to 430) faced the problem of reconciling an omnipotent, wholly good Creator with evil. He held that evil has no positive nature but is the privation of good (City of God XI.9), and that all evil is either sin or the punishment of sin.

The theory

Where it succeeds

Where it fails

Alternatives

Conclusion

Augustine's account is coherent as a theory of moral evil but fails as a complete account of natural evil; its reliance on a historical fall and inherited punishment is its weakest point.

Examples and data to cite

Facts

Facts to remember

Sources used for the explanation

Write a timed answer in the app