How does the issue of moral autonomy conflict with conception of religion as a source of morality ? Critically discuss.
15 marks · directive: Critically discuss
The core of a good answer
If morality is what God commands, moral agents seem heteronomous, obeying an external authority rather than a law they recognise by reason (Kant), and the Euthyphro dilemma makes morality either arbitrary or independent of God; the conflict eases if God commands what is good in itself and conscience freely recognises it.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
Critically discuss asks for both sides. Define moral autonomy and the religious source view, set out the arguments for conflict, the theistic replies, and reach a reasoned conclusion.
Answer outline
Introduction
Moral autonomy, in Kant's Groundwork of the Metaphysics of Morals (1785), means that the rational will gives the moral law to itself; heteronomy is acting under a law imposed from outside. Divine command theory holds that an act is right because God commands it.
Arguments for conflict
- Euthyphro dilemma (Plato): is something good because God commands it, or does God command it because it is good? The first makes morality arbitrary; the second makes it independent of God.
- Kant: the moral law must be self imposed (autonomy); divine command theory has been read as an example of what Kant called a heteronomous will, which he regarded as non moral.
Replies
- Natural law (Aquinas): scholars usually place him on the first horn; unchangeable moral standards form the bulk of natural law, and what is moral serves the purpose of human existence, so it can be known through human nature.
- Modified divine command theory (Robert Adams): an act is wrong if and only if it defies the commands of a loving God; since goodness rests on God's essential goodness, God cannot be sadistic.
Assessment
- The conflict is sharpest for a strong command theory; it softens where religion offers motivation, community and vision while reason tests content.
Conclusion
Moral autonomy does not abolish religion's moral role, but it requires that religious commands be open to the judgement of conscience; religion is then a source of moral vision rather than the ground of obligation.
Examples and data to cite
- Plato, Euthyphro 10a: is the pious loved by the gods because it is pious, or pious because it is loved?
- Robert Adams's modified divine command theory: wrongness as contrary to the commands of a loving God.
Facts to remember
- Kant's Groundwork, 1785: autonomy, the self imposition of the moral law.
- The Euthyphro dilemma comes from Plato's dialogue Euthyphro.
- Divine command theory: rightness depends on God's commands.