Does the idea of Religious Pluralism necessarily entail moral relativism ? Critically discuss.
15 marks · directive: Critically discuss
The core of a good answer
No: religious pluralism holds that several religions are valid paths to the ultimate, but it usually rests on a shared moral criterion (Hick's transformation from self centredness to Reality centredness, the Golden Rule), so it presupposes common moral standards rather than relativism; it slides into relativism only if pluralism is extended to every moral practice.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
The question tests a logical link: does accepting many valid religions force us to accept that morality is relative? Define both, show the argument for entailment, then show why the link fails, and conclude.
Answer outline
Introduction
Religious pluralism, in John Hick's An Interpretation of Religion (1989), holds that the great traditions are different human responses to one ultimate Reality. Moral relativism holds that moral truth is relative to cultures or individuals, with no universal standard.
Why it might seem to entail relativism
- If no religion is uniquely true, religious moral codes lose a single authority.
- Different religions endorse different practices (diet, family law, rites), suggesting moral variety.
- Tolerance of all religions may be confused with tolerance of all practices.
Why it does not
- Hick's criterion of validity is ethical: a tradition is authentic insofar as it produces transformation from self centredness to Reality centredness, seen in compassion and love; so pluralism uses a common moral yardstick.
- The Golden Rule is found in many religious and ethical traditions; the Parliament of the World's Religions (Chicago, 1993) adopted 'Towards a Global Ethic', first drafted by Hans Küng, which makes it a fundamental demand.
- Pluralism concerns truth about the ultimate, not about right and wrong; one can be a pluralist about paths and a universalist about ethics.
- Pluralism itself rests on universal values (respect, non violence), which a full relativist cannot affirm.
- Indian thought: the Rigveda says 'Reality is one, though wise men speak of it variously', a universalist view that sits alongside universal virtues such as ahimsa and satya.
Critical points
- Distinguishing core ethics from cultural practice is difficult; pluralists must say why a practice such as caste discrimination is not protected.
- Exclusivists argue pluralism waters down each religion's moral demands.
Conclusion
Religious pluralism does not necessarily entail moral relativism; properly understood it presupposes shared moral standards that let us judge practices within all religions.
Examples and data to cite
- Declaration Toward a Global Ethic, Parliament of the World's Religions, Chicago, 1993.
- Hick, An Interpretation of Religion (1989); Hick gave the Gifford Lectures in 1986 to 1987.
Facts to remember
- Hick's soteriological criterion: transformation from self centredness to Reality centredness.
- Rigveda: Reality is one, though wise men speak of it variously.
- Moral relativism denies universal moral truth.