Analyse R. M. Hare’s concept of ‘blik’ and assess whether it successfully defends the meaningfulness of religious language.
20 marks · directive: Analyse; Assess
The core of a good answer
Hare's 'blik' is a basic, unfalsifiable way of seeing the world (like the lunatic's conviction that dons want to murder him, or a driver's trust in the steel of his steering) which nonetheless makes a real difference to how we live; it shows that religious language can be meaningful without being falsifiable, but at the cost of making it non cognitive and leaving no way to judge between sane and insane bliks.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
Two tasks: analyse the concept (context, parable, features) and assess its success as a defence of religious language, weighing strengths against criticisms by Flew, Mitchell and others.
Answer outline
Introduction
In the 'Theology and Falsification' symposium (reprinted in Flew and MacIntyre's New Essays in Philosophical Theology, 1955), Antony Flew argued, using the parable of the invisible gardener (adapted from John Wisdom's 'Gods'), that religious assertions die the death of a thousand qualifications because believers allow nothing to count against them. R. M. Hare replied with the concept of a blik.
Analysis of blik
- Parable: a lunatic is convinced that all dons want to murder him; however kind the dons are, he sees it as cunning. No evidence counts against his belief.
- Hare: the difference between him and us is our respective bliks; he has an insane blik about dons, we have a sane one.
- Example: Hare's confidence that the steel joints of his car's steering will hold rests on no tests he has made; a person with the opposite blik could not be cured by any number of safe arrivals or bench tests.
- Features: unfalsifiable, not an explanation, yet it governs action and interpretation of all facts; Hare credits Hume with showing that our whole commerce with the world depends on our bliks.
- Religious belief is a blik: it is meaningful because it makes a difference to how one lives and sees the world.
Strengths
- Shows that not all meaningful convictions are empirical hypotheses.
- Captures the role religion plays as a total outlook.
- Points to framework beliefs.
Weaknesses
- Non cognitivism: if religious claims are bliks, they assert nothing about God, which most believers reject.
- Sane vs insane: Hare's own language implies some bliks are correct, but he offers no criterion to tell them apart.
- Mitchell, agreeing with Flew, held that theological utterances must be assertions; Hare's bliks are not assertions.
- Basil Mitchell's parable of the partisan and the stranger argued that believers do allow evidence (evil) to count against faith, but not decisively, so faith is cognitive and trusting.
- John Hick's eschatological verification gave another, cognitive reply.
Conclusion
The blik successfully shows that religious language is not empty, but it defends meaningfulness by giving up truth claims; most philosophers therefore see it as a partial and costly defence.
Examples and data to cite
- Flew, Hare and Mitchell, 'Theology and Falsification', reprinted in New Essays in Philosophical Theology (eds. Flew and MacIntyre, 1955).
- John Wisdom, 'Gods', source of the gardener parable.
Facts to remember
- Blik: an unfalsifiable but life guiding outlook (Hare).
- Mitchell's parable: the partisan and the stranger.