Present an account of criticisms against omniscience and omnipotence as attributes of God.
15 marks · directive: Present an account
The core of a good answer
Omnipotence is attacked by paradoxes (the stone too heavy to lift), by its conflict with evil and with God's goodness, and omniscience by its conflict with human freedom (foreknowledge), with God's immutability and timelessness (knowing what time it is, indexical knowledge) and by logical arguments that there is no set of all truths; theists answer by defining the attributes within logical limits.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
Present an account asks for an organised description of the criticisms, with sources, and the main replies, rather than a single argument.
Answer outline
Introduction
Classical theism holds that God is omnipotent (can do all things) and omniscient (knows all truths). Both attributes have been challenged on logical, moral and metaphysical grounds.
Against omnipotence
- Paradox of the stone: can God create a stone he cannot lift? Either answer suggests a limit (discussed by George Mavrodes, 1963).
- Mackie, 'Evil and Omnipotence' (1955): the essential theistic doctrines are inconsistent with one another, since an omnipotent, wholly good God could have made beings who act freely but always go right; he also distinguished first order omnipotence (unlimited power to act) from second order omnipotence (unlimited power to determine what powers beings have).
- Moral perfection: if God is powerless to bring about evil, it seems there is something he cannot do.
- Reply: Aquinas held that omnipotence is the power to do whatever is logically possible; contradictions are not things at all.
Against omniscience
- Foreknowledge and freedom: if God knows today what I will do tomorrow, I cannot do otherwise (Nelson Pike, 1965). Replies: Boethius's timeless eternity, Ockham, Molina's middle knowledge, open theism.
- Immutability: Norman Kretzmann (1966) argued that a being that always knows what time it is must change, so an omniscient being cannot be immutable.
- Indexical knowledge: knowing, as Jones does, that he himself is in hospital seems open only to the person concerned; Kretzmann concluded that omniscience clashes with the doctrine of a personal God distinct from other persons.
- Patrick Grim's Cantorian argument: there is no set of all truths, so there is nothing for omniscience to know as a totality.
Combined criticisms
- Problem of evil: an all knowing, all powerful God would know of and could prevent evil, which is why Mackie held the theistic doctrines to be inconsistent.
- Incoherence of the set: some argue the attributes cannot all be possessed together with perfect goodness and freedom.
Conclusion
The criticisms show that omnipotence and omniscience must be carefully defined; most theists now restrict them to the logically possible and knowable, which answers the paradoxes but leaves the problems of evil and freedom open.
Examples and data to cite
- Mackie, 'Evil and Omnipotence', Mind, 1955.
- Pike, 'Divine Omniscience and Voluntary Action', 1965.
- Kretzmann, 'Omniscience and Immutability', 1966.
Facts to remember
- Aquinas: omnipotence covers whatever does not involve a contradiction (Summa Theologiae I, q.25, a.3).
- Boethius, Consolation of Philosophy: God's knowledge is timeless.
- Mackie's 'Evil and Omnipotence' appeared in Mind in 1955.