What is meant by achromatic combination of lenses? Derive the condition for achromatization of a pair of lenses separated by a distance x. The two lenses have different dispersive powers.
20 marks · directive: Derive
The core of a good answer
An achromatic combination has the same focal length for two chosen colours; for thin lenses of focal lengths f₁, f₂ and dispersive powers ω₁, ω₂ separated by x, setting d(1/F) = 0 gives x = (ω₁f₂ + ω₂f₁)/(ω₁ + ω₂), which reduces to x = (f₁ + f₂)/2 when both lenses are of the same glass.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
Definition plus a derivation of the condition for removing longitudinal chromatic aberration of a separated doublet. The method is to differentiate the equivalent focal length formula with respect to refractive index, using d(1/f) = ω/f for each lens.
Answer outline
Introduction
Chromatic aberration arises because μ, and hence focal length, depends on wavelength. A combination is achromatic when the equivalent focal length F is the same for two wavelengths (usually C and F lines), i.e. d(1/F) = 0 for a small change in wavelength.
Step 1: Dispersive power and a single lens
- Lens maker's formula: 1/f = (μ − 1)(1/R₁ − 1/R₂) = (μ − 1)K.
- d(1/f) = K dμ = (dμ/(μ − 1))(1/f) = ω/f, where ω = dμ/(μ − 1) is the dispersive power.
Step 2: Equivalent focal length of two separated thin lenses
- 1/F = 1/f₁ + 1/f₂ − x/(f₁f₂)
Step 3: Differentiate
- d(1/F) = d(1/f₁) + d(1/f₂) − x d[(1/f₁)(1/f₂)]
- = ω₁/f₁ + ω₂/f₂ − x[(1/f₂)(ω₁/f₁) + (1/f₁)(ω₂/f₂)]
- = ω₁/f₁ + ω₂/f₂ − x(ω₁ + ω₂)/(f₁f₂)
Step 4: Condition for achromatism
- Set d(1/F) = 0 and multiply by f₁f₂: ω₁f₂ + ω₂f₁ = x(ω₁ + ω₂)
- x = (ω₁f₂ + ω₂f₁)/(ω₁ + ω₂)
Step 5: Special cases
- Same material (ω₁ = ω₂): x = (f₁ + f₂)/2; this is the basis of the Huygens eyepiece. For the Ramsden eyepiece (two lenses of equal focal length f) the condition would need x = f, which is not used in practice, so that design is not fully corrected.
- Lenses in contact (x = 0): ω₁/f₁ + ω₂/f₂ = 0, so the lenses must be of opposite sign and of different glasses (crown and flint).
- The condition makes F the same for two colours only, and holds for the equivalent focal length, not the position of the principal planes.
Conclusion
For a separated pair, x = (ω₁f₂ + ω₂f₁)/(ω₁ + ω₂); for one glass, x = (f₁ + f₂)/2. Check: x = 0 recovers the contact doublet condition ω₁/f₁ + ω₂/f₂ = 0.
Examples and data to cite
- Huygens eyepiece: two plano-convex lenses of glass with the same Abbe number, separated by an air gap, free of transverse chromatic aberration.
- Crown and flint achromatic doublet for lenses in contact: first made by Chester Moore Hall; John Dollond patented the design in 1758.
Facts to remember
- Dispersive power ω = dμ/(μ − 1) (the Abbe number is its reciprocal measure).
- Equivalent focal length of two thin lenses: 1/F = 1/f₁ + 1/f₂ − d/(f₁f₂).
- d(1/f) = ω/f for a thin lens.
- Achromatism in contact: ω₁/f₁ + ω₂/f₂ = 0.