Consider a particle of mass m in two dimensions experiencing a central force F⃗ = −kr⃗, where k is a positive constant and r⃗ is the radius vector of the particle relative to the force center.
(i) What is the angular momentum J⃗ of the particle relative to the force center? Show that J⃗ is conserved.
(ii) Write down the system of equations of motion in two dimensions in polar coordinates. Reduce this system to a one-equation problem and find the equation for the effective potential energy U_eff.
15 marks · directive: Show
The core of a good answer
J⃗ = r⃗ × mv⃗ = mr²θ̇ ẑ is conserved because the torque r⃗ × (−kr⃗) = 0; the polar equations m(r̈ − rθ̇²) = −kr and d(mr²θ̇)/dt = 0 reduce, with θ̇ = J/mr², to mr̈ = −kr + J²/mr³, i.e. a one dimensional problem with U_eff(r) = (1/2)kr² + J²/(2mr²).
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
Central force motion for an isotropic harmonic force. The question carries 6 + 9 = 15 marks for (i) and (ii). The method: torque zero gives conserved angular momentum; Newton's law in polar components; eliminate θ̇ using J.
Answer outline
Introduction
Polar coordinates (r, θ) in the plane, unit vectors r̂, θ̂. Force F⃗ = −kr r̂, potential U(r) = (1/2)kr².
Step 1: (i) Angular momentum
- v⃗ = ṙ r̂ + rθ̇ θ̂
- J⃗ = r⃗ × mv⃗ = mr² θ̇ ẑ (perpendicular to the plane of motion), magnitude J = mr²θ̇.
Step 2: (i) Conservation
- dJ⃗/dt = v⃗ × mv⃗ + r⃗ × F⃗ = 0 + r⃗ × (−kr⃗) = 0
- So J⃗ is constant in magnitude and direction; the motion stays in a plane and sweeps equal areas in equal times (dA/dt = J/2m).
Step 3: (ii) Equations of motion in polar coordinates
- Acceleration: a⃗ = (r̈ − rθ̇²) r̂ + (rθ̈ + 2ṙθ̇) θ̂
- Radial: m(r̈ − rθ̇²) = −kr
- Transverse: m(rθ̈ + 2ṙθ̇) = 0, i.e. (1/r) d(mr²θ̇)/dt = 0
Step 4: Reduction to one equation
- From the transverse equation: θ̇ = J/(mr²).
- Radial: mr̈ = −kr + J²/(mr³)
- Write as mr̈ = −dU_eff/dr with U_eff(r) = (1/2)kr² + J²/(2mr²).
Step 5: Energy form and features
- E = (1/2)mṙ² + U_eff(r) = constant.
- U_eff has a minimum at r₀⁴ = J²/(mk): a circular orbit with angular speed √(k/m).
- General orbits are ellipses centred on the force centre (the isotropic oscillator), with period 2π√(m/k).
Conclusion
J = mr²θ̇ is conserved and the radial motion is governed by U_eff = kr²/2 + J²/2mr². Check: for J = 0 the problem reduces to simple harmonic motion along a line.
Examples and data to cite
- The isotropic two dimensional oscillator is one of the two central forces (with the inverse square force) that always give closed orbits, by Bertrand's theorem.
Facts to remember
- Torque τ⃗ = r⃗ × F⃗ = dJ⃗/dt; a central force exerts no torque about the centre.
- Polar acceleration components: r̈ − rθ̇² and rθ̈ + 2ṙθ̇.
- Effective potential U_eff = U(r) + J²/(2mr²).
- Bertrand's theorem: the linear (Hooke) and inverse square central forces are the only ones that guarantee closed orbits.