Two solids A and B have Debye temperatures 200 K and 300 K respectively. At T = 20 K, compare their specific heats.
10 marks · directive: Compare
Answer
The core of a good answer
At T = 20 K both solids are well below their Debye temperatures, so the Debye T³ law C = (12π⁴/5)R(T/θ_D)³ applies and C_A/C_B = (θ_B/θ_A)³ = (300/200)³ = 3.375; numerically C_A ≈ 1.94 J mol⁻¹ K⁻¹ and C_B ≈ 0.576 J mol⁻¹ K⁻¹.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
An application of the low temperature limit of the Debye model. The method is to check that T ≪ θ_D, then use C ∝ (T/θ_D)³.
Answer outline
Introduction
Given θ_A = 200 K, θ_B = 300 K, T = 20 K. T/θ_A = 0.1 and T/θ_B = 0.067, both small, so the T³ law is a good approximation.
Step 1: Debye T³ law
- C_V = (12π⁴/5) N k (T/θ_D)³ per mole (Nk = R)
- 12π⁴R/5 = 1944 J mol⁻¹ K⁻¹
Step 2: Ratio
- C_A/C_B = (θ_B/θ_A)³ = (300/200)³ = 3.375
Step 3: Actual values
- C_A = 1944 × (20/200)³ = 1.94 J mol⁻¹ K⁻¹
- C_B = 1944 × (20/300)³ = 0.576 J mol⁻¹ K⁻¹
Step 4: Interpretation
- A lower θ_D means softer lattice and lower phonon frequencies, so more modes are excited at 20 K and the heat capacity is higher.
- Both are far below the Dulong-Petit value 3R = 24.9 J mol⁻¹ K⁻¹.
Conclusion
Solid A has about 3.4 times the specific heat of solid B at 20 K. Check: 1.944/0.576 = 3.375.
Examples and data to cite
- Lead (θ_D about 105 K) has a much larger low temperature heat capacity than diamond (θ_D about 2230 K).
Facts
Facts to remember
- Debye T³ law: C_V = (12π⁴/5)R(T/θ_D)³ for T ≪ θ_D.
- Debye temperature θ_D = ħω_D/k.
- High temperature limit: Dulong-Petit, C_V = 3R.