A gas has only two particles a and b. Show with the help of diagrams how these two particles can be arranged in three energy states 1, 2, 3 using (i) Maxwell-Boltzmann, (ii) Fermi-Dirac and (iii) Bose-Einstein statistics.
20 marks · directive: Show
The core of a good answer
Maxwell-Boltzmann treats a and b as distinguishable with no limit per state, giving 3² = 9 arrangements; Bose-Einstein treats them as identical with no limit, giving 6; Fermi-Dirac treats them as identical with at most one per state, giving 3.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
Counting microstates under the three statistics. The answer must state the rules (distinguishability and occupancy) and then list every arrangement in a table or box diagram for each case, ending with the counts and the general formulae.
Answer outline
Introduction
Write each arrangement as (state 1 | state 2 | state 3). Particles a and b; states 1, 2, 3 of equal weight.
(i) Maxwell-Boltzmann: distinguishable, any number per state (9)
- (ab | − | −), (− | ab | −), (− | − | ab)
- (a | b | −), (b | a | −)
- (a | − | b), (b | − | a)
- (− | a | b), (− | b | a)
- Total 3² = 9
(ii) Bose-Einstein: identical (write both as a), any number per state (6)
- (aa | − | −), (− | aa | −), (− | − | aa)
- (a | a | −), (a | − | a), (− | a | a)
- Total (n + g − 1)!/[n!(g − 1)!] = 4!/(2!2!) = 6
(iii) Fermi-Dirac: identical, at most one per state (Pauli principle) (3)
- (a | a | −), (a | − | a), (− | a | a)
- Total g!/[n!(g − n)!] = 3!/(2!1!) = 3
Comparison
- Probability that both particles share a state: MB 3/9 = 1/3, BE 3/6 = 1/2, FD 0.
- Bosons show bunching (a tendency to crowd together), fermions show exclusion; MB lies between.
- MB applies to classical particles at high temperature and low density, BE to photons, FD to electrons.
Diagrams
- In the answer draw three boxes (levels 1, 2, 3) for each arrangement and place the particles as dots labelled a and b (MB) or unlabelled dots (BE, FD), giving 9, 6 and 3 panels.
Conclusion
Two particles in three states give 9 (MB), 6 (BE) and 3 (FD) arrangements. Check by direct enumeration: 9, 6 and 3.
Examples and data to cite
- Electrons in metals (Fermi-Dirac) explain the small electronic heat capacity; Bose-Einstein condensation was first achieved experimentally in 1995.
Facts to remember
- MB: gⁿ arrangements for n distinguishable particles in g states.
- BE: (n + g − 1)!/[n!(g − 1)!].
- FD: g!/[n!(g − n)!], n ≤ g.
- Bosons have integer spin; fermions half integer spin and obey the Pauli exclusion principle.