If the position and momentum operators in 1-D are represented by x̂ and p̂ respectively, calculate the commutator [x̂², cos (p̂)].
10 marks · directive: Calculate
The core of a good answer
Using [x̂, f(p̂)] = iħ f′(p̂), [x̂², cos p̂] = −iħ(x̂ sin p̂ + sin p̂ x̂), which can also be written −2iħ x̂ sin p̂ − ħ² cos p̂ (or −2iħ sin p̂ x̂ + ħ² cos p̂).
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
An operator-algebra derivation. The method is to prove (or quote) [x̂, f(p̂)] = iħ df/dp̂ from [x̂, p̂] = iħ, then use the product rule [AB, C] = A[B, C] + [A, C]B. The examiner will want the steps, and a neat final form.
Answer outline
Introduction
Start from the canonical commutator [x̂, p̂] = iħ. Here cos(p̂) is defined by its power series (p̂ treated as dimensionless, as printed).
Step 1: [x̂, p̂ⁿ]
- [x̂, p̂ⁿ] = iħ n p̂ⁿ⁻¹ (by induction using [x̂, p̂ⁿ] = [x̂, p̂]p̂ⁿ⁻¹ + p̂[x̂, p̂ⁿ⁻¹])
- Summing the power series: [x̂, f(p̂)] = iħ f′(p̂)
- So [x̂, cos p̂] = −iħ sin p̂
Step 2: Product rule
- [x̂², C] = x̂[x̂, C] + [x̂, C]x̂
- [x̂², cos p̂] = −iħ(x̂ sin p̂ + sin p̂ x̂)
Step 3: Ordered forms
- x̂ sin p̂ = sin p̂ x̂ + [x̂, sin p̂] = sin p̂ x̂ + iħ cos p̂
- Hence [x̂², cos p̂] = −2iħ sin p̂ x̂ + ħ² cos p̂ = −2iħ x̂ sin p̂ − ħ² cos p̂
Step 4: Check in momentum representation
- In p-space x̂ = iħ d/dp; acting on a test function g(p), x̂²(cos p g) − cos p x̂²g = −2iħ sin p (iħ g′) + ħ² cos p g, which matches the result (verified symbolically).
Conclusion
[x̂², cos p̂] = −iħ{x̂, sin p̂} = −2iħ x̂ sin p̂ − ħ² cos p̂. The result is anti-Hermitian, as a commutator of two Hermitian operators must be.
Facts to remember
- Canonical commutation relation [x̂, p̂] = iħ.
- [x̂, f(p̂)] = iħ f′(p̂) and [p̂, g(x̂)] = −iħ g′(x̂).
- [AB, C] = A[B, C] + [A, C]B.
- In momentum representation x̂ = iħ ∂/∂p.