(i) Why does the electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) spectroscopy utilize the microwave region of the electromagnetic spectrum, while nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) uses radio waves?
(ii) Why can the experimental observation of the Lamb shift not be explained by the Dirac theory?
15 marks · directive: Explain
The core of a good answer
EPR flips an electron spin whose moment (about μ_B) is roughly 1836 times larger than the nuclear magneton, so at a typical 0.35 T field the resonance is near 9.8 GHz (microwave) while proton NMR at the same field is near 15 MHz (radio). The Lamb shift (2S₁/₂ lying about 1057 MHz above 2P₁/₂) cannot come from Dirac theory because the Dirac equation makes all levels with the same n and j exactly degenerate; the splitting arises from radiative (QED) effects, the electron's interaction with vacuum fluctuations of the quantised field.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
Two conceptual parts (7 + 8 marks). Part (i) needs the resonance condition hν = gμB with numbers to show the frequency ranges. Part (ii) needs what Dirac theory predicts for hydrogen (degeneracy in j), what Lamb and Retherford measured in 1947, and why quantum electrodynamics is needed.
Answer outline
Introduction
Both are magnetic resonance methods: a photon of energy hν = gμB flips a magnetic moment between Zeeman levels. The size of the moment fixes the frequency. For part (ii), contrast Dirac's energy formula with experiment.
(i) Resonance condition
- hν = g μ_B B for an electron (g ≈ 2); hν = g_N μ_N B for a nucleus
- μ_B/μ_N = 9.274 × 10⁻²⁴ / 5.051 × 10⁻²⁷ ≈ 1836 (the proton to electron mass ratio)
(i) Numbers
- At B = 0.35 T (X-band EPR): ν = 2 × 9.274 × 10⁻²⁴ × 0.35/h ≈ 9.8 GHz, wavelength about 3 cm: microwaves
- Proton NMR at the same 0.35 T: ν = 5.5856 μ_N B/h ≈ 14.9 MHz; even at 9.4 T it is only about 400 MHz: radio waves
- So for practical laboratory fields the electron Zeeman splitting falls in the microwave region, the nuclear one in the radio-frequency region
(ii) What Dirac theory predicts
- Dirac energy depends only on n and j, so 2S₁/₂ and 2P₁/₂ (both j = 1/2) are exactly degenerate
- Dirac theory already includes spin-orbit coupling, the relativistic mass correction and the Darwin term
(ii) What was observed
- Lamb and Retherford (1947), using microwaves to drive transitions between 2S₁/₂ and 2P₁/₂ in hydrogen, found 2S₁/₂ raised above 2P₁/₂; the shift is about 1057 MHz (about 4.4 × 10⁻⁶ eV)
- This lifting of degeneracy is outside any single-particle Dirac solution in a Coulomb field
(ii) Explanation by QED
- The electron interacts with the quantised radiation field: zero-point (vacuum) fluctuations make its position jitter, smearing the Coulomb potential it feels
- Bethe (1947) explained the shift with mass renormalisation, the start of modern quantum electrodynamics
Conclusion
EPR and NMR differ in frequency because the electron magnetic moment is about 1836 times the nuclear one; the Lamb shift is a radiative effect of field quantisation, which the Dirac equation (a relativistic single-particle theory with a classical Coulomb field) does not contain.
Examples and data to cite
- Proton NMR spectrometers are named by frequency, for example 400 MHz (about 9.4 T from hν = g_N μ_N B with the given constants).
- Lamb received the 1955 Nobel Prize in Physics for discoveries on the fine structure of the hydrogen spectrum.
Facts to remember
- Resonance condition hν = gμB; μ_B = 9.274 × 10⁻²⁴ J/T, μ_N = 5.051 × 10⁻²⁷ J/T.
- X-band EPR: about 9 to 10 GHz at about 0.35 T.
- Lamb shift: 2S₁/₂ to 2P₁/₂ splitting of about 1057 MHz in hydrogen, Lamb and Retherford, 1947.
- Dirac energy levels of hydrogen depend only on n and j.