Are the nucleons inside the nucleus governed by the laws of quantum physics? Justify your answer.
10 marks · directive: Justify
The core of a good answer
Yes: nucleons are bound within the femtometre range of the nuclear force, where a nucleon's de Broglie wavelength is larger than that range and the uncertainty principle forces kinetic energies of the order of MeV, so classical orbits are meaningless; nuclei also show shell structure with magic numbers, obey the Pauli principle as fermions and carry quantised spins used in NMR, all of which are quantum effects.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
A justification question: give a clear yes, then support it with order-of-magnitude estimates (de Broglie wavelength, uncertainty principle) and with experimental facts that only quantum mechanics explains. A short calculation adds weight.
Answer outline
Introduction
The nuclear force is strongly attractive at nucleon separations of about 0.8 fm and negligible beyond about 2 fm, so nucleons are confined to femtometre distances; nucleon rest energy is about 939 MeV.
Scale argument
- Confinement to Δx ≈ 2 fm gives Δp ≈ ħ/Δx and a kinetic energy (Δp)²/2m ≈ (197.3/2)²/(2 × 939) ≈ 5 MeV: of the order of MeV, so confinement energy is large
- A nucleon of 8 MeV has λ = h/p ≈ 10 fm, larger than the range of the nuclear force: wave behaviour cannot be ignored
- Hence classical trajectories are not defined; the Schrödinger equation with a fitted nucleon potential is used to obtain nuclear properties
Shell structure
- Magic numbers 2, 8, 20, 28, 50, 82, 126: nuclei with these nucleon numbers are especially tightly bound
- The shell model explains them with quantised single-particle levels filled according to the Pauli principle, plus spin-orbit coupling
Fermion statistics and spin
- Nucleons are fermions: two identical nucleons cannot occupy the same state, which is why the nuclear force binds a proton and a neutron (deuteron) but not two identical nucleons in the same spin state
- Nuclear spins are quantised; nuclei with non-zero spin are used in NMR, while even-even nuclei have zero spin
Conclusion
Nucleons are quantum objects; nuclear structure can only be described by quantum mechanics, with the strong force supplying the potential.
Facts to remember
- Nuclear force: attractive at about 0.8 fm, negligible beyond about 2 fm.
- Uncertainty principle Δx Δp ≥ ħ/2 (Kennard, 1927).
- Nuclear magic numbers: 2, 8, 20, 28, 50, 82, 126.
- Nucleons are fermions and obey the Pauli exclusion principle.