What do you understand by the packing fraction ‘f’ and the binding energy ‘E_b’ of a nucleus? Draw the graphs for packing fraction f versus mass number (A) and binding energy fraction f_b (= E_b/A) versus mass number (A). Further, explain how the graphs of the variation of f and f_b with A have complementary approaches.
10 marks · directive: Explain
The core of a good answer
Packing fraction f = (M − A)/A (M the atomic mass in u) and binding energy E_b = [Zm_H + Nm_n − M]c²; f is positive for light nuclei, falls through zero to a minimum near A ≈ 50 to 60 and rises again for heavy nuclei, while E_b/A rises steeply to about 8.8 MeV near A ≈ 56 to 62 (⁵⁶Fe, ⁶²Ni) and then falls slowly for heavier nuclei, so one curve is roughly the mirror image of the other: f ≈ constant − f_b/931.5 MeV.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
Define both quantities with formulas, sketch the two curves with their key features (described in words here), and show algebraically why low packing fraction corresponds to high binding energy per nucleon. A few computed values make the sketches concrete.
Answer outline
Introduction
Atomic masses in u; 1 u = 931.5 MeV/c² (given). m_H = m_p + mₑ = 1.0078252 u; m_n = 1.0086652 u.
Definitions
- Mass defect Δ = M − A (in u); packing fraction f = (M − A)/A, often quoted × 10⁴
- Binding energy E_b = [Z m_H + (A − Z) m_n − M] × 931.5 MeV; binding energy fraction f_b = E_b/A
- f is zero for ¹²C by definition of the mass unit
Sample values (given masses)
- ⁴He: E_b = 28.30 MeV, f_b = 7.07 MeV, f = +6.5 × 10⁻⁴
- ¹²C: E_b = 92.16 MeV, f_b = 7.68 MeV, f = 0
- ¹⁶O: E_b = 127.62 MeV, f_b = 7.98 MeV, f = −3.2 × 10⁻⁴
- ¹H: f = +7.8 × 10⁻³ (large and positive)
Graph of f versus A
- Large positive for the lightest nuclei, drops steeply, crosses zero near A = 12 to 16
- Negative minimum in the iron-group region
- Rises slowly, becoming positive again for the heaviest nuclei
Graph of f_b versus A
- Rises steeply for light nuclei, with ⁴He and ¹⁶O standing out as particularly stable
- Broad maximum about 8.8 MeV near A ≈ 56 to 62 (⁵⁶Fe and ⁶²Ni about 8.79 MeV)
- Slow fall for heavier nuclei, because Coulomb repulsion between protons grows
Complementary nature
- From the definitions: f = [Z(m_H − 1) + N(m_n − 1)]/A − f_b/931.5
- The first term is nearly constant (about 8 × 10⁻³), so f ≈ 0.008 − f_b/931.5: where f_b is high, f is low
- Both curves show that energy is released by fusion of light nuclei and fission of heavy nuclei, moving toward the iron-group region
Conclusion
The packing fraction curve is essentially the inverted binding-energy-per-nucleon curve: minimum f and maximum E_b/A both sit in the iron-group region, marking the most stable nuclei.
Facts to remember
- Packing fraction f = (M − A)/A.
- E_b = [Z m_H + N m_n − M]c², 1 u = 931.5 MeV/c².
- Maximum E_b/A ≈ 8.8 MeV near A ≈ 56 to 62.
- f ≈ constant − (E_b/A)/931.5 MeV, so the two curves are mirror images.