What is the criticality of a self-sustained nuclear reactor? Write the basic processes affecting the nuclear chain reactions of a finite-size nuclear reactor. Also, write the critical size of reactors of different shapes in terms of geometrical buckling constant.
20 marks · directive: Explain
The core of a good answer
A reactor is critical when its effective multiplication factor k_eff (neutrons in one generation divided by those in the previous one) equals 1, so the chain reaction is self-sustaining at constant power; in a finite reactor k_eff = ηεpf × P_FNL × P_TNL, set by fission yield, fast fission, resonance escape, thermal utilisation and leakage. Criticality requires geometric buckling B_g² to equal material buckling B_m² = (k∞ − 1)/M², with B_g² = (π/R)² for a sphere (R = π/B), (2.405/R)² + (π/H)² for a cylinder, (π/a)² + (π/b)² + (π/c)² for a box (cube a = √3π/B) and (π/a)² for a slab.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
A 20-mark descriptive and formula answer: define k and the three regimes, list the life-cycle processes with the four (six) factor formula, then state the diffusion-theory critical condition and the buckling of each geometry, ideally with minimum critical volumes.
Answer outline
Introduction
In a thermal reactor a neutron generation goes: fission, fast neutrons, slowing down in the moderator, thermal neutrons absorbed in fuel, new fission. Some neutrons are lost in each stage, and in a finite reactor some leak out.
Criticality
- k_eff < 1: subcritical, neutron population dies out; k_eff = 1: critical, steady chain reaction; k_eff > 1: supercritical, power rises
- Reactivity measures the departure from criticality; control rods and moderator conditions keep the reactor near k_eff = 1
Basic processes (six-factor formula)
- η: neutrons produced per thermal neutron absorbed in fuel (typical thermal-reactor value 1.65)
- ε: fast fission factor (fission by fast neutrons, slightly above 1, typically 1.02)
- p: resonance escape probability (avoiding capture in ²³⁸U resonances while slowing down)
- f: thermal utilisation (fraction of thermal neutrons absorbed in fuel rather than moderator and structure)
- P_FNL and P_TNL: fast and thermal non-leakage probabilities, which depend on size and shape
- k∞ = ηεpf (infinite medium); k_eff = k∞ P_FNL P_TNL
Critical condition
- One-group diffusion: ∇²φ + B²φ = 0 in the core; material buckling B_m² = (k∞ − 1)/L² (or (k∞ − 1)/M² with migration area M² = L² + τ)
- Geometric buckling B_g² is the lowest eigenvalue fixed by φ = 0 at the extrapolated boundary
- Critical when B_g² = B_m²; equivalently k_eff = k∞/(1 + M²B²) = 1
Critical size by shape
- Sphere of radius R: B² = (π/R)², critical R = π/B
- Infinite slab of thickness a: B² = (π/a)², a = π/B
- Rectangular parallelepiped a × b × c: B² = (π/a)² + (π/b)² + (π/c)²; cube a = √3 π/B
- Finite cylinder of radius R and height H: B² = (2.405/R)² + (π/H)² (2.405 is the first zero of J₀)
- Dimensions are extrapolated ones (actual size plus an extrapolation distance set by the transport mean free path)
Minimum critical volumes
- Sphere: V = 4π⁴/(3B³) = 130/B³ (smallest, least surface per volume)
- Cylinder at optimum H = 1.85R: V = 148/B³
- Cube: V = 3√3π³/B³ = 161/B³
Conclusion
Criticality means k_eff = 1, reached when the core is just large enough that B_g² = B_m²; for a given material the sphere needs the least volume, then the optimum cylinder, then the cube.
Facts to remember
- k_eff = ηεpf P_FNL P_TNL; k∞ = ηεpf (four-factor formula).
- Criticality: B_g² = B_m² = (k∞ − 1)/M².
- Geometric buckling: sphere (π/R)², cylinder (2.405/R)² + (π/H)², parallelepiped (π/a)² + (π/b)² + (π/c)², slab (π/a)².
- Minimum critical volumes: sphere 130/B³, cylinder 148/B³, cube 161/B³.