(i) Discuss the Debye model of lattice specific heat. What are the limitations of the Debye model?
(ii) At very low temperatures, the specific heat of rock salt varies with temperature according to the Debye T³ law. The Debye temperature for rock salt is 281 K. How much heat will be required to raise the temperature of 2 kilo-mol of rock salt from 10 K to 50 K?
15 marks · directive: Discuss
The core of a good answer
(i) Debye treats the solid as an elastic continuum whose 3N vibrational modes (phonons, ω = vk) are cut off at the Debye frequency ω_D (θ_D = ħω_D/k_B), giving C = 9Nk_B(T/θ_D)³∫₀^(θ_D/T) x⁴eˣ/(eˣ − 1)² dx, which tends to 3Nk_B at high T and to (12π⁴/5)Nk_B(T/θ_D)³ at low T; its limits come from the linear dispersion, single cutoff and neglect of optical modes, electrons and anharmonicity. (ii) Q = n(12π⁴/5)R(T₂⁴ − T₁⁴)/(4θ_D³) = 2.73 × 10⁵ J (about 273 kJ) for n = 2 kmol, R = 8314 J kmol⁻¹ K⁻¹.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
Part (i) (10 marks): model assumptions, density of states, the integral, the two limits and specific limitations. Part (ii) (5 marks): integrate the T³ law between the limits. State the per-mole convention used, because NaCl has two ions per formula unit.
Answer outline
Introduction
Debye model: N atoms, 3N modes, density of states g(ω) = 9Nω²/ω_D³ up to ω_D. For (ii): C = (12π⁴/5)R(T/θ_D)³ per mole, Q = n∫C dT.
(i) Assumptions
- Solid is an isotropic elastic continuum; all three acoustic branches have the same sound speed v and linear dispersion ω = vk
- Number of modes is limited to 3N, fixing a cutoff ω_D = v(6π²N/V)^(1/3)
- Modes are quantised oscillators (phonons) obeying Bose-Einstein statistics
(i) Result and limits
- U = ∫ g(ω) ħω/(e^(ħω/kT) − 1) dω; C = 9Nk(T/θ)³ ∫₀^(θ/T) x⁴eˣ/(eˣ − 1)² dx
- T ≫ θ_D: C → 3Nk = 3R per mole (Dulong-Petit)
- T ≪ θ_D: C = (12π⁴/5)Nk(T/θ_D)³ (T³ law), in agreement with experiment, unlike the Einstein model's exponential fall
(i) Limitations
- Real dispersion is not linear: a constant sound speed is good for low-energy phonons but not for high-energy ones, causing errors at intermediate temperatures
- A single cutoff for all branches (longitudinal and transverse) is unrealistic
- Extra dispersion branches (optical branches) in crystals with more than one atom per cell are not captured
- θ_D fitted from C(T) varies with temperature, showing the model is approximate
- Ignores the electronic specific heat of metals, which dominates the lattice term at very low T
(ii) Calculation
- C = (12π⁴/5)R(T/θ_D)³ = 233.78 × (R/θ_D³) × T³ per kmol
- Q = n(12π⁴/5)(R/θ_D³) ∫₁₀^⁵⁰ T³ dT = n(12π⁴/5)(R/θ_D³)(50⁴ − 10⁴)/4
- = 2 × 233.78 × 8314/(281)³ × 1.56 × 10⁶ J
- Q = 2.73 × 10⁵ J ≈ 273 kJ
Conclusion
Heat required ≈ 2.73 × 10⁵ J, treating each kilomole as N_A vibrating units, as the question intends. If each Na⁺ and Cl⁻ ion is counted as an atom (2 per formula unit), the answer doubles to 5.47 × 10⁵ J. At 50 K (θ_D/T ≈ 5.6) the T³ law already overestimates C; the full Debye function gives about 2.26 × 10⁵ J.
Facts to remember
- Debye low-temperature law: C_V = (12π⁴/5)Nk_B(T/θ_D)³.
- Dulong-Petit limit: C_V = 3R per mole at T ≫ θ_D.
- θ_D = ħω_D/k_B.
- R = 8.314 J mol⁻¹ K⁻¹ = 8314 J kmol⁻¹ K⁻¹.