Write on the following in about 150 words each :
(a) Resurgence of political theory
10 marks · answer in 150 words · directive: Write a short note
The core of a good answer
After the behavioural revolution some scholars in the 1950s declared political philosophy dead; it revived from the 1960s and decisively with John Rawls's A Theory of Justice (1971), because questions of justice, rights and legitimacy could not be settled by empirical science alone.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
The part asks you to explain what declined, why it was thought to be dead, and what brought it back. A 150 word note should date the 'decline' debate, name the thinkers and works of the revival, and say what the revival changed in the discipline.
Answer outline
Introduction
In the mid-twentieth century behaviouralism, and the view (a side-effect of logical positivism) that ethical statements have no truth value, pushed normative questions aside, and some scholars announced the death of political philosophy.
The 'decline' thesis
- Peter Laslett, introducing Philosophy, Politics and Society (1956), declared that the tradition of political philosophy written in English, from Hobbes to Bosanquet, was dead.
- Laslett attributed part of the decline to the view, a side-effect of logical positivism, that ethical statements of all kinds had no truth value.
Signs of revival
- Isaiah Berlin, 'Does Political Theory Still Exist?' (1962), answered yes: as long as people disagree about the ends of society, political theory cannot become extinct.
- David Easton, in his presidential address to the American Political Science Association in September 1969 ('The New Revolution in Political Science'), announced a 'post-behavioral revolution' whose battle cries were relevance and action.
- Rawls's A Theory of Justice (1971) restored systematic normative theory; Robert Nozick's Anarchy, State, and Utopia answered it from the libertarian side.
What the revival brought
- New debates on justice and equality, libertarianism, feminism and communitarianism.
- A closer link between theory and public policy, for example capability theory and human development.
Conclusion
The resurgence showed that empirical science and normative reasoning are complementary: facts can tell us what is, but political theory is still needed to judge what ought to be.
Examples and data to cite
- John Rawls, A Theory of Justice (1971).
- David Easton, 'The New Revolution in Political Science', APSA presidential address (1969).
- Isaiah Berlin, 'Does Political Theory Still Exist?' (1962).
Facts to remember
- Easton had been one of the leading advocates of the behavioural revolution before announcing the post-behavioural revolution in 1969.
- Easton named relevance and action as the battle cries of the post-behavioural revolution (1969).
- Rawls's two principles of justice (equal basic liberties; fair equality of opportunity and the difference principle) are chosen behind a 'veil of ignorance' in the 'original position'.