Write on the following in about 150 words each :
(c) The freedom of the pike is death to the minnows.
10 marks · answer in 150 words · directive: Write a short note
The core of a good answer
The aphorism, used by Isaiah Berlin in 'Two Concepts of Liberty' (1958), means that unrestricted liberty for the strong destroys the liberty of the weak; so 'the liberty of some must depend on the restraint of others', and freedom has to be limited and protected by law if it is to be real for everyone.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
Explain the meaning of the statement, its source and its place in the debate on negative and positive liberty, and then show what follows for the role of the State. Bring in the liberal answer (harm principle) and the egalitarian answer (positive liberty, welfare State).
Answer outline
Introduction
In 'Two Concepts of Liberty', his inaugural lecture at Oxford on 31 October 1958, Isaiah Berlin wrote: 'Freedom for the pike is death for the minnows'; the liberty of some must depend on the restraint of others.
Meaning
- Pike is a predatory fish and minnows are small fish: absolute liberty in an unequal society becomes the freedom of the powerful to dominate.
- Berlin used it to show that even negative liberty (freedom from interference) must be limited: the liberty of some must depend on the restraint of others.
Liberal and egalitarian readings
- J.S. Mill's harm principle (On Liberty, 1859): power may rightly be exercised over a member of a civilised community, against his will, only to prevent harm to others.
- Laissez-faire capitalism, child labour and monopoly are classic cases of the pike's freedom.
Indian application
- Directive Principles such as Article 38 (minimise inequalities in income) and Article 39 (protect workers and children from exploitation) direct the State to restrain the strong to give freedom to the weak.
- Article 19(2) to (6) allow reasonable restrictions on the freedoms of Article 19(1).
Conclusion
The statement is not an argument against liberty but for regulated liberty: freedom is secured for all only when the State restrains those who would destroy the freedom of others.
Examples and data to cite
- Isaiah Berlin, 'Two Concepts of Liberty', Oxford, 31 October 1958.
- Article 19(2) to (6), Constitution of India: reasonable restrictions on fundamental freedoms.
Facts to remember
- Berlin distinguished negative liberty (freedom from interference) from positive liberty (self-mastery).
- Mill's On Liberty was published in 1859.