“Rights of the man are separate and independent of the State.” Critically analyze the perspective of Laski.
20 marks · directive: Critically analyze
The core of a good answer
Laski did not treat rights as natural rights independent of society, but he did hold that rights are prior to the State in validity: the State does not create rights but recognises them, and 'every State is known by the rights that it maintains'; rights are 'those conditions of social life without which no man can seek, in general, to be himself at his best'.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
The question puts a natural-rights reading to Laski; a critical analysis must show what in his theory supports it (rights as prior to the State, the State judged by rights, pluralism) and what does not (rights are social, functional and tied to duties). End with an evaluation of strengths and weaknesses.
Answer outline
Introduction
Harold Laski (1893 to 1950) developed his theory of rights in A Grammar of Politics (1925) and Liberty in the Modern State (1930). He began as a pluralist critic of State sovereignty and later moved towards Marxism.
Where Laski supports the statement
- Rights are prior to the State in the sense that, recognised or not, they are that from which its validity derives; every State is known by the rights that it maintains.
- Rights are those conditions of social life without which no man can seek, in general, to be himself at his best.
- As a pluralist (Studies in the Problem of Sovereignty, 1917; Authority in the Modern State, 1919), he held that the State is not supreme and that people owe loyalties also to bodies such as trade unions and clubs.
- To deny the claims of right is to sacrifice the claim to allegiance: resistance can become a duty when the State denies rights.
Where Laski rejects the statement
- Rights are not natural in the sense that a permanent and unchanging catalogue of them can be compiled; they are not independent of society but inherent in it.
- Rights are correlative with functions: a right is claimed as a member of society contributing to the common good.
- The State needs power to maintain rights: 'If the State is known by the rights that it maintains, clearly it needs the power to maintain those rights.'
Content of rights in Laski
- Political rights: a share in choosing rulers regardless of sex, property, race or creed; freedom of expression and of association.
- Economic and social rights: work, an adequate wage, reasonable hours of labour and education; liberty and equality are at the base of the political system.
- This links him to the welfare State and the British Labour Party.
Critical evaluation
- Strength: subjects State power to a moral test and joins liberty to economic equality.
- Weakness: ambiguity between rights as prior to the State and rights as recognised by it; the test of 'best self' is open to dispute.
- His later Marxist phase (from the 1930s) saw the State as serving the owners of property, which undermines the idea of a neutral recogniser of rights.
Indian connection
- The Constitution reflects this balance: Part III limits the State (Article 13) while Part IV directs it to create social and economic conditions for rights.
Conclusion
Laski's position is best read not as natural-rights individualism but as a social theory in which rights are independent of any particular government's will yet realised only through a just State.
Examples and data to cite
- Harold Laski, A Grammar of Politics (1925).
- Harold Laski, Liberty in the Modern State (1930).
- Article 13, Constitution of India: laws inconsistent with fundamental rights are void to the extent of the inconsistency.
Facts to remember
- Laski's pluralist works: Studies in the Problem of Sovereignty (1917), Authority in the Modern State (1919), The Foundations of Sovereignty (1921).
- Herbert Deane dates Laski's Marxian phase to 1932 to 1939.
- Laski taught at the London School of Economics and was chairman of the Labour Party in 1945 to 1946.