“Fortune favours the brave.” In the light of this statement, discuss Machiavelli’s concepts of ‘virtue’ and ‘fortune’.
15 marks · directive: Discuss
The core of a good answer
For Machiavelli fortune is the arbiter of half of human actions and virtù, the bold, adaptable and decisive capacity of the ruler, can direct the rest; in Chapter 25 of The Prince he concludes that boldness is better than caution, because fortune is more easily mastered by the bold and the young.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
The answer should explain the two concepts, show how they interact in The Prince and the Discourses, and test the proverb: virtù is more than courage, and even the bold can be ruined by fortune.
Answer outline
Introduction
Niccolò Machiavelli (1469 to 1527) wrote The Prince (written 1513, published 1532) and the Discourses on Livy. Fortuna and virtù are the paired concepts through which he explains political success and failure.
Fortuna
- Chapter 25 of The Prince: fortune is the arbiter of one-half of our actions, leaving the rest for us to direct.
- Image of a raging river: in quiet times people can prepare defences and barriers so that the flood is channelled safely.
Virtù
- Not moral virtue but political capability: intelligence to know what must be done and the will to do it, including bravery, skill and forcefulness; the prince must learn to be both lion (force) and fox (deception) (Chapter 18).
- The ruler must be able to change his conduct with the times; failure comes from inflexibility.
- Examples: Moses, Cyrus, Romulus and Theseus owed nothing to fortune beyond opportunity (Chapter 6); Cesare Borgia acquired his state during the ascendancy of his father and lost it on its decline (Chapter 7).
Fortune favours the brave
- Machiavelli concludes that bold action is better than caution, because fortune, which he likens to a woman, is mastered by force, and the young are bolder in taking control of her.
- Pope Julius II succeeded by acting impetuously; his short life spared him the times when caution was needed.
- So boldness is part of virtù, but the wider lesson is adaptability and preparation.
Critical note
- Hanna Pitkin's Fortune is a Woman (1984) examines gender and politics in Machiavelli's thought, including the gendered image of fortune.
- Its realist approach influenced later thinkers such as Bacon, Hobbes and Spinoza.
Conclusion
The proverb captures one side of Machiavelli: virtù is courage joined to foresight and flexibility, and only that combination can turn fortune into political success.
Examples and data to cite
- The Prince, Chapter 25: fortune the arbiter of half of our actions; the river image.
- The Prince, Chapter 7: Cesare Borgia, who acquired his state through his father's ascendancy.
- Hanna Pitkin, Fortune is a Woman (1984).
Facts to remember
- The Prince was written in 1513 and published in 1532.
- Machiavelli separates politics from conventional morality, so virtù is not moral virtue.