Discuss Gandhi’s approach to property in relation to trusteeship.
15 marks · directive: Discuss
The core of a good answer
Gandhi held that wealth beyond what a person needs for a livelihood belongs to the community; its holder should act as a trustee using it for the common good, and the Practical Trusteeship Formula (published in Harijan, 25 October 1952) offered a non-violent path from capitalism to an egalitarian order, with private ownership only as far as society permits.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
Discuss Gandhi's view of property (non-possession, bread labour, critique of both capitalism and violent expropriation), explain trusteeship, and assess its relevance and criticisms.
Answer outline
Introduction
Gandhi rejected both unrestrained capitalism and forcible expropriation. His idea of trusteeship asks the owners of wealth to hold what exceeds their needs in trust for society.
Gandhi on property
- Wealth beyond what a person needs for a livelihood belongs to society: 'The rest of my wealth belongs to the community and must be used for the welfare of the community.'
- Gandhi's approach relied on persuading the wealthy to give up their wealth voluntarily rather than on force.
The Practical Trusteeship Formula
- Drafted by Narhari Parikh and Kishorelal Mashruwala after their release from prison, refined by M.L. Dantwala, with a few changes by Gandhi; published in Harijan on 25 October 1952.
- Trusteeship provides a means of transforming the present capitalist order into an egalitarian one; it gives no quarter to capitalism but gives owners a chance to reform.
- Private ownership only so far as permitted by society for its own welfare; legislative regulation of ownership and use of wealth is not ruled out.
- A minimum living wage and a maximum income, with the gap reduced over time.
- Production determined by social necessity, not personal whim or greed.
Assessment
- Relevance: Section 135 of the Companies Act, 2013 requires companies above net worth, turnover or profit thresholds to spend at least 2 per cent of profits on CSR; the Bhoodan movement of Vinoba Bhave began at Pochampally on 18 April 1951.
- Criticism: it relies on the goodwill of the rich; socialist critics saw it as siding with big landowners, feudal rulers and business owners.
- Supporters see it as a moral economy that joins ethics and economics; J.R.D. Tata built his personal and professional life around it.
Conclusion
Trusteeship is Gandhi's attempt to reconcile property with equality through moral change backed by social pressure and law, and its appeal has grown with debates on ethical business.
Examples and data to cite
- Practical Trusteeship Formula, Harijan, 25 October 1952.
- Section 135, Companies Act, 2013: mandatory CSR for companies above specified thresholds.
- Bhoodan movement, begun by Vinoba Bhave at Pochampally (now in Telangana) on 18 April 1951.
Facts to remember
- Gandhi: wealth beyond one's livelihood belongs to the community and must be used for its welfare.
- Narhari Parikh and Kishorelal Mashruwala drafted the formula after their release from prison; Gandhi made a few changes.