When there are multiple stakeholders of power, conversation and consensus become the natural ingredients of governance. Analyze with respect to coalition politics.
15 marks · directive: Analyze
The core of a good answer
Coalition governments in India have had to govern through common programmes and accommodation of allies and regional parties, which made consultation and consensus part of governance; this widened federal and social representation, though it also brought instability, policy paralysis and bargaining by smaller partners.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
Analyse the claim using the Indian experience of coalitions since 1989: show the mechanisms of conversation and consensus, their benefits and their costs.
Answer outline
Introduction
Coalition governments form when no party wins a majority. India had coalition governments from 1989 (National Front) through the NDA (1999 to 2004) and UPA (2004 to 2014); in 2024 it returned to an NDA-led coalition as the BJP failed to win a majority.
Mechanisms of consensus
- The UPA's early policies were guided by a common minimum programme worked out in consultation with Left Front leaders.
- Consultation with allies and with Chief Ministers; the NDA itself has no formal governing structure.
Benefits
- Regional parties brought State concerns to the Union, strengthening cooperative federalism.
- Broader social representation in Cabinets.
- Moderation of extreme agendas and more deliberation on legislation.
Costs
- Instability: the first NDA government collapsed within a year when the AIADMK withdrew support; the Left Front withdrew support from the UPA in 2008 over the India-US nuclear agreement.
- Veto by partners: the Trinamool Congress left the UPA in 2012 citing, among other things, the decision to allow FDI in retail.
- Transactional bargaining for portfolios and packages.
Recent experience
- In 2024 the BJP won 240 of 543 seats and the NDA 293, with the TDP (16) and JD(U) (12) as key partners.
- Article 75(1A) caps the Council of Ministers at 15 per cent of the total membership of the Lok Sabha, limiting coalition patronage.
Conclusion
Coalitions make conversation and consensus unavoidable; whether this becomes good governance depends on institutional mechanisms and shared programmes rather than ad hoc bargaining.
Examples and data to cite
- UPA common minimum programme (2004).
- First NDA government (1998), which collapsed within a year when the AIADMK withdrew support.
- 2024 Lok Sabha result: BJP 240, NDA 293 of 543.
Facts to remember
- Article 75(1A): the total number of Ministers, including the Prime Minister, shall not exceed 15 per cent of the total number of members of the Lok Sabha.
- Article 75(3): the Council of Ministers is collectively responsible to the Lok Sabha.