Evaluate the Centre-State relation with reference to Article 293 and analyze its implications for the Indian federal structure.
15 marks · directive: Evaluate; Analyze
The core of a good answer
Article 293 lets a State borrow within India on the security of its Consolidated Fund but requires the Union's consent for any loan while a Union loan or guarantee is outstanding; this consent, which may carry conditions, gives the Union real control over State borrowing, a point now before a Constitution Bench in Kerala's suit (referred on 1 April 2024).
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
Evaluate the provision and its working, then analyse its effect on fiscal federalism, citing the conflict over net borrowing ceilings.
Answer outline
Introduction
Article 293 governs borrowing by States and their relationship with the Union as lender.
Text of Article 293
- 293(1): a State's executive power extends to borrowing within the territory of India upon the security of its Consolidated Fund, within limits fixed by its legislature.
- 293(2): the Government of India may make loans or guarantees to States.
- 293(3): a State may not raise a loan without the Union's consent if any part of a loan made by the Union (or its predecessor government) is still outstanding.
- 293(4): the consent may be granted subject to conditions.
How it works
- The Union fixes annual net borrowing ceilings for States; for Kerala in 2023-24 the ceiling was 3 per cent of projected GSDP.
- The Union's borrowing limits are communicated to States by letter; Kerala challenges letters of 27 March 2023 and 11 August 2023.
- For 2023-24 the Union counted borrowings of State-owned enterprises and Public Account liabilities within Kerala's ceiling.
The Kerala dispute
- Kerala filed an Article 131 suit (Original Suit No. 1 of 2024) on 8 December 2023 against the net borrowing ceiling and the 28 March 2018 amendment to the FRBM Act.
- On 1 April 2024 the Supreme Court refused interim relief and referred the case to a five-judge Constitution Bench, with questions on the scope of Article 293 and on fiscal decentralisation under federalism.
Implications for federalism
- Supports macro-fiscal discipline: the Court cited wider effects on national finances in refusing interim relief.
- But it tilts fiscal power to the Union.
- States argue that conditions intrude on their autonomy; one question before the Bench is whether States must be consulted on Finance Commission recommendations.
Conclusion
Article 293 reflects the centralising design of Indian fiscal federalism; its legitimacy depends on transparent, consultative and non-discriminatory use of the consent power.
Examples and data to cite
- State of Kerala v. Union of India: suit filed 8 December 2023; referred to a Constitution Bench on 1 April 2024.
- Union's net borrowing ceiling for Kerala in 2023-24 was 3 per cent of projected GSDP.
Facts to remember
- Article 293(1) allows a State to borrow only within the territory of India.
- Kerala's suit was filed under Article 131 as Original Suit No. 1 of 2024.