Highlight any five constitutional provisions that restrain the powers of the executive, and evaluate their effectiveness in current times.
15 marks · directive: Highlight; Evaluate
The core of a good answer
The Constitution restrains the executive through collective responsibility to the Lok Sabha, judicial review, limits on ordinances and emergencies, legislative control of finance and independent audit; these have worked unevenly, because a large majority, weak parliamentary scrutiny and delays in courts can blunt them.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
Pick five clear provisions, explain each briefly, and evaluate each against recent practice.
Answer outline
Introduction
In a parliamentary system the executive is drawn from and responsible to the legislature, and limited by a written Constitution.
1. Collective responsibility (Article 75(3))
- The Council of Ministers is collectively responsible to the Lok Sabha; no-confidence motions and question hour test it.
- Effectiveness: weak under strong majorities; Question Hour functioned for 60 per cent of scheduled time in the 17th Lok Sabha (PRS).
2. Judicial review (Articles 13 and 32, and the High Courts)
- Courts strike down unconstitutional action; for example the electoral bond scheme was struck down on 15 February 2024.
- Effectiveness: strong in principle but pendency and delayed hearings reduce it.
3. Ordinances (Article 123)
- Only when both Houses are not in session and the President is satisfied that circumstances render immediate action necessary; ordinances cease six weeks after Parliament reassembles.
- Ordinances are thus temporary, and Parliament can disapprove them earlier by resolution.
4. Emergency powers (Articles 352, 356)
- Article 352 now requires 'armed rebellion' (the 1950 text said 'internal disturbance'), a decision of the Union Cabinet communicated in writing, and approval by a majority of the total membership and two-thirds of members present and voting in each House.
- S.R. Bommai (1994) made Article 356 proclamations subject to judicial review and required the majority to be tested on the floor of the Assembly.
5. Financial control and audit (Articles 148 to 151)
- Parliament votes the budget; the CAG audits expenditure from the Consolidated Funds and its reports are laid before Parliament and the State legislatures.
- Effectiveness: about 80 per cent of the budget was voted without discussion between 2019 and 2023, and the entire 2023 budget passed without discussion (PRS).
Conclusion
The provisions remain sound, but their force depends on an active Parliament, an independent judiciary and robust institutions; reforms should revive parliamentary scrutiny.
Examples and data to cite
- S.R. Bommai v. Union of India (1994).
- Electoral bond scheme struck down by the Supreme Court, 15 February 2024.
- PRS, Functioning of the 17th Lok Sabha (2024): Question Hour functioned for 60 per cent of scheduled time.
Facts to remember
- Article 74(1) proviso: the President may require the Council of Ministers to reconsider its advice, and must act on the advice tendered after reconsideration.
- Article 123(2): an ordinance ceases to operate six weeks after the reassembly of Parliament.