Critically comment on the shifts in the functioning of the Indian Parliament in the last two decades.
15 marks · directive: Critically comment
The core of a good answer
In the 17th Lok Sabha Parliament met less, referred fewer bills to committees and debated bills and budgets less, while suspensions of MPs were frequent; at the same time it gained a new building and important legislation, so the shift is towards executive dominance rather than legislative decline alone.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
A critical comment needs data on the shifts, their causes and a balanced judgement, with some positive developments.
Answer outline
Introduction
Parliament's core functions are law-making, financial control, executive accountability and representation.
Shifts (17th Lok Sabha, 2019 to 2024, PRS data)
- 274 sittings, the fewest of any full-term Lok Sabha.
- Only 16 per cent of bills referred to committees for detailed scrutiny.
- 35 per cent of bills passed with less than an hour of Lok Sabha debate.
- The Lok Sabha did not elect a Deputy Speaker for its entire duration, the first time this has happened.
- Question Hour functioned for 60 per cent of scheduled time in Lok Sabha.
- MPs were suspended on 206 instances across both Houses.
Causes
- Strong majorities, party whips and the anti-defection law; disruption as an opposition strategy; reduced sessions.
Positive developments
- New Parliament House inaugurated on 28 May 2023; Constitution (106th Amendment) Act, 2023.
- Rahul Gandhi was recognised as Leader of the Opposition in the 18th Lok Sabha (2024) after the post stayed vacant through the 16th and 17th.
Critical view
- Executive dominance and weak scrutiny reduce quality of law; reforms: fixed minimum sittings, mandatory committee referral, opposition days.
Conclusion
Parliament has shifted from a forum of deliberation towards a ratifier of executive decisions; restoring scrutiny is essential for accountable government.
Examples and data to cite
- PRS, Functioning of the 17th Lok Sabha (2024).
- Article 93: Deputy Speaker to be chosen 'as soon as may be'.
Facts to remember
- In 2023 the entire Union budget was passed without discussion (PRS).
- Only 14 private members' bills have been passed and received assent; none has been passed by both Houses since 1970.