Answer the following questions in about 150 words each :
Discuss various methods of Balance of Power.
10 marks · answer in 150 words · directive: Discuss
The core of a good answer
States preserve a balance of power through internal balancing (armaments) and external balancing (alliances); Morgenthau's classical list adds divide and rule, compensations and the role of a 'holder' of the balance; later variants include soft balancing, while bandwagoning and buck passing are alternatives to balancing.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
The directive asks for a discussion of the methods, so the answer should list them, explain each with a historical example and note limits. About 150 words: classify methods into internal and external, then add the classical techniques listed by Morgenthau in Politics Among Nations.
Answer outline
Introduction
Balance of power is a situation, and a policy, in which power is distributed so that no single state can dominate the others.
Internal and external balancing
- Armaments: building one's own capabilities (internal balancing, Waltz); Morgenthau calls the armaments race the typical instrument of an unstable, dynamic balance.
- Alliances and counter-alliances: coalitions against a rising or threatening power (external balancing).
Classical techniques (Morgenthau)
- Divide and rule: keeping rivals divided or weak.
- Compensations: dividing territory so that the distribution of power stays about the same, as when Austria, Prussia and Russia partitioned Poland.
- Holder of the balance: a power that waits in detachment and supports the side likely to lose; Morgenthau calls Great Britain the classic example.
Contemporary variants and limits
- Soft balancing: a concept developed to explain the apparent absence of hard balancing against the United States in a unipolar world.
- Walt's balance of threat: states balance against threats, not power alone; weaker states may bandwagon instead.
- Buck passing and chain-ganging show that balancing can fail or drag allies into war, as before the First World War.
Conclusion
The methods aim at equilibrium rather than peace, and nuclear weapons and interdependence have changed but not ended their use.
Examples and data to cite
- Treaty of Utrecht (1713) explicitly invoked the balance of power.
- England's long policy of preventing any one power from dominating the continent; Morgenthau calls Great Britain the classic holder of the balance.
Facts to remember
- Waltz distinguishes internal balancing (own efforts) from external balancing (alliances).
- Stephen Walt's balance of threat theory holds that states respond to threats, not just to power.
- Soft balancing was developed to explain the absence of hard balancing against the United States in the unipolar era.