Discuss the factors responsible for the changing nature of states in contemporary industrial societies and explain its impact.
20 marks · directive: Discuss; Explain
The core of a good answer
Globalisation of capital and finance, neoliberal restructuring, technological change, supranational and multilevel governance, and new social demands have moved industrial states from the positive, welfare and producer state towards a regulatory, competition and networked state; this has reduced direct economic control and reshaped welfare and accountability, but has not produced the retreat of the state, which returned as investor, protector and security provider after 2008 and 2020.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
Two tasks: discuss the factors, then explain the impact. Organise factors as economic, technological, political-institutional and social, and impacts on economy, welfare, democracy and sovereignty, with named concepts (Strange, Majone, Cerny) and recent examples.
Answer outline
Introduction
The post-war industrial state was a Keynesian welfare state that owned industries, managed demand and expanded social rights. Since the 1970s its form and functions have changed.
Economic factors
- Mobility of capital and the growth of global financial markets; Susan Strange described a see-saw of power between markets and political authority and a 'dangerous gap' between global markets and territorially bounded states.
- Fiscal crisis of the welfare state and the neoliberal turn: privatisation, deregulation, independent central banks.
- Deindustrialisation and the move to service and knowledge economies.
Technological factors
- Information technology, platforms and data create new powers (surveillance, digital public infrastructure) and new limits (cross-border data, cyber threats).
Political and institutional factors
- Supranational integration (EU), global rules (WTO) and multilevel governance share authority upward and downward.
- Use of agencies, regulators and networks rather than direct provision: Majone's shift 'from the positive to the regulatory state' (1997).
- Cerny's 'competition state' (1997): the state is remade along the lines of a business-like organisation in a global environment, and the pursuit of competitiveness can expand rather than shrink intervention and regulation.
Social factors
- Ageing populations, migration, identity politics and environmental demands add new tasks.
Impact
- Economy: less ownership, more rule-setting; the state as regulator and market maker.
- Welfare: retrenchment and targeting, conditional benefits.
- Democracy: power moves to unelected agencies and courts, raising accountability gaps and populist backlash.
- Sovereignty: shared and pooled rather than lost; after 2008 and the pandemic the state returned as rescuer, investor (industrial policy) and protector of supply chains.
Conclusion
The industrial state has been transformed rather than diminished: it governs more through rules and partnerships, and crises keep reviving its interventionist core.
Examples and data to cite
- Susan Strange, The Retreat of the State: The Diffusion of Power in the World Economy (1996).
- Philip Cerny, 'Paradoxes of the Competition State: The Dynamics of Political Globalization', Government and Opposition (1997).
- Giandomenico Majone, 'From the Positive to the Regulatory State' (1997).
Facts to remember
- Strange distinguished relational power from structural power and identified security, production, finance and knowledge structures (States and Markets, 1988).
- Regulatory state: expansion through regulation rather than taxing and spending.