The island of Kachchatheevu remains an intractable issue in India-Srilanka relations. Comment.
15 marks · directive: Comment
The core of a good answer
Legally the issue was settled when India recognised Sri Lankan sovereignty over Kachchatheevu in the 1974 agreement, but it stays intractable because it is tied to the livelihood of Tamil Nadu fishermen, the 1976 restrictions on fishing in each other's waters, friction with the Sri Lankan Navy and Tamil Nadu politics; a solution lies in managing fisheries rather than reopening sovereignty.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
Comment means give a reasoned view: explain the legal position, why the dispute persists, and possible ways forward.
Answer outline
Introduction
Kachchatheevu is an uninhabited island of about 285 acres in the Palk Strait between Rameswaram and Neduntheevu.
Legal position
- Agreement on the Boundary in Historic Waters (signed 26 and 28 June 1974): each side has sovereignty on its side of the line, which placed the island with Sri Lanka.
- Article 5: Indian fishermen and pilgrims enjoy access to visit Kachchativu 'as hitherto' without travel documents or visas.
- Article 6: vessels of both countries enjoy the rights they have traditionally enjoyed in each other's waters.
- 1976 agreement on the maritime boundary in the Gulf of Mannar and Bay of Bengal (23 March 1976), with an exchange of letters regulating Sri Lankan fishing in the Wadge Bank; fishermen of each country were barred from fishing in the other's waters.
Why it remains intractable
- Livelihoods: Indian fishermen fish in Sri Lankan waters, bringing them into conflict with the Sri Lankan Navy.
- Politics: Tamil Nadu petitioned the Supreme Court in 2011 against the 1974 and 1976 agreements, and the Assembly passed a resolution in March 2025 seeking retrieval.
- Constitutional debate: petitioners relied on the Berubari reference; the Union said in 2014 that no Indian territory was ceded because the area had been in dispute.
Ways forward
- Joint fisheries mechanisms, licensed fishing or leasing arrangements, deep-sea fishing support and humane treatment of fishermen.
Conclusion
Kachchatheevu is a fisheries and federal politics problem more than a sovereignty dispute, and should be handled through livelihood solutions that respect the 1974 settlement.
Examples and data to cite
- Tamil Nadu Assembly resolution, March 2025.
- Tamil Nadu's 2011 petition in the Supreme Court.
Facts to remember
- The annual church festival on the island runs for three days, with priests from both countries conducting services.
- 1974 agreement signed 26 June (Colombo) and 28 June 1974 (New Delhi).