India has recognised that West Asia is not a single contest, but a tangle of rivalries, bargains and anxieties. Comment.
15 marks · directive: Comment
The core of a good answer
India's West Asia policy reflects the view that the region has several overlapping contests (Israel and Iran, Saudi Arabia and Iran, Gulf rivalries, great power competition) rather than one Arab-Israeli divide; so it de-hyphenates its relations, pursues separate bargains with Israel, the Gulf monarchies and Iran, and protects its anxieties about energy, diaspora and sea lanes, as seen in the 2025 and 2026 crises.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
Comment: explain the claim, show how India's policy reflects it, and assess its strengths and limits, using recent events.
Answer outline
Introduction
West Asia supplies much of India's energy, hosts over 9 million Indians in the six GCC states, and is crossed by sea lanes vital to India.
Rivalries
- Israel against Iran and its partners; Saudi Arabia and Iran; intra-Gulf divisions; US, Russian and Chinese competition.
- The war launched by the US and Israel on Iran on 28 February 2026, in which Iran blocked the Strait of Hormuz and struck Gulf targets.
Bargains
- Abraham Accords normalisation, I2U2 (2022) and IMEC (MoU of 9 September 2023) link India to Israel and the Gulf.
- Saudi Arabia and Pakistan signed a Strategic Mutual Defence Agreement on 17 September 2025.
- India's separate tracks: Special Strategic Partnership with Israel (February 2026), energy and investment with Saudi Arabia and the UAE, connectivity through Chabahar with Iran.
Anxieties
- Energy prices and supply: LPG and oil stress in India in March 2026.
- Safety of the diaspora: Operation Sindhu evacuated over 4,400 Indians from Iran and Israel in June 2025.
- Remittances (the GCC accounts for nearly 40% of India's roughly $135 billion) and shipping security.
Assessment
- De-hyphenation lets India deal with all sides and avoid entanglement.
- But crises can force choices, and India's influence over outcomes is limited.
Conclusion
India's approach of balanced, issue-based engagement suits a fragmented region, but it requires more naval capacity and energy diversification to protect its interests.
Examples and data to cite
- Operation Sindhu, June 2025: over 4,400 Indian nationals evacuated.
- Saudi-Pakistan Strategic Mutual Defence Agreement, 17 September 2025.
Facts to remember
- IMEC MoU signed 9 September 2023.
- I2U2 formed in 2022 (India, Israel, UAE, US).