Answer the following questions in about 150 words each :
(e) How do the ‘leaky bucket’ and ‘working memory’ approaches differ in their explanation of the short-term memory?
10 marks · answer in 150 words · directive: Explain
The core of a good answer
The leaky bucket image fits the short-term store of the Atkinson and Shiffrin (1968) modal model, which treats short-term memory as a single, passive, limited store from which items leak away unless rehearsed, whereas Baddeley and Hitch's working memory model (1974) treats it as an active workspace of several components that hold and manipulate information for thinking.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
The question asks for a contrast of two models of the same system. In about 150 words, describe each briefly and then compare them on structure, function, capacity and evidence.
Answer outline
Introduction
Short-term memory holds a small amount of information for a few seconds. The leaky bucket metaphor pictures it as a bucket of limited size with a hole: information drains out unless it is topped up by rehearsal.
Leaky bucket (unitary store) view
- One store, about seven plus or minus two items (Miller, 1956), lost by decay or displacement within seconds.
- Its main role is a gateway: rehearsal keeps items in the store and transfers them to long-term memory.
- Passive: storage, not processing.
Working memory view
- Multiple components: central executive (attention control, updating, task-shifting, inhibition), phonological loop, visuo-spatial sketchpad, and the episodic buffer added by Baddeley in 2000.
- Active: information is held in order to be used in reasoning, comprehension and learning.
- Domain-specific stores with separate limits.
Key differences and evidence
- Dual-task studies: two tasks using separate perceptual domains (visual and verbal) can be done together nearly as efficiently as alone, which a single store cannot explain.
- Phonological similarity and articulatory suppression effects point to a speech-based loop.
Conclusion
The working memory approach did not deny limited capacity; it replaced a passive container with a system of interacting processes, which better fits everyday cognition.
Examples and data to cite
- Holding a phone number while dialling uses the phonological loop; mentally rotating a map uses the visuo-spatial sketchpad.
- Mental arithmetic such as 37 x 4 needs both storage and processing, illustrating the working memory idea.
Facts to remember
- Atkinson and Shiffrin proposed the multi-store (modal) model in 1968.
- Baddeley and Hitch proposed working memory in 1974; the episodic buffer was added in 2000.
- Miller (1956) gave the span of short-term memory as about seven plus or minus two items.