Answer the following questions in about 150 words each :
(c) Examine the role of causal attribution in the formation of prejudice and discrimination.
10 marks · answer in 150 words · directive: Examine
The core of a good answer
Causal attribution feeds prejudice when people explain out-group members' bad acts by their character and their good acts by circumstance, while doing the reverse for their own group (the ultimate attribution error); such biased explanations confirm stereotypes, justify hostile feelings and legitimise discriminatory treatment.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
Examine asks you to probe the link closely: define attribution, show the specific biases that turn explanations into prejudice, support with studies, and note how correcting attributions can reduce discrimination.
Answer outline
Introduction
Attribution is the process of inferring the causes of behaviour, internal (dispositional) or external (situational), first analysed by Fritz Heider (1958). Prejudice is a negative attitude towards a group; discrimination is the behaviour that follows from it.
Biases that link attribution to prejudice
- Fundamental attribution error: overestimating dispositional causes of others' behaviour.
- Ultimate attribution error (Pettigrew, 1979): out-group failures and misdeeds are attributed internally and out-group successes externally (luck, special help); in-group behaviour is explained the opposite way.
- Belief in a just world: victims of poverty or violence are blamed for their fate, justifying unequal treatment.
Evidence
- Duncan (1976): white participants judged an ambiguous shove as violent and dispositional when done by a Black actor, but situational when done by a white actor.
- Taylor and Jaggi (1974), in South India: Hindu participants explained in-group misdeeds externally and out-group (Muslim) misdeeds internally.
From attribution to discrimination
- The ultimate attribution error reinforces negative stereotypes of the out-group and favouritism of the in-group; in criminal justice, minority groups may face harsher sentences and a higher chance of conviction. Weiner's theory classifies causes by locus, stability and controllability, and blaming others brings anger and disrespect.
Remedies
- Attributional retraining, which helps people reconsider external and controllable factors, and awareness of situational causes can reduce biased attributions.
Conclusion
Prejudice is sustained not only by feelings but by everyday explanations, so changing how people explain others' behaviour is a route to reducing discrimination.
Examples and data to cite
- Duncan's ambiguous shove study (1976).
- Taylor and Jaggi's Hindu and Muslim attribution study in South India (1974).
Facts to remember
- Pettigrew proposed the ultimate attribution error in 1979.
- Heider's The Psychology of Interpersonal Relations (1958) founded attribution theory.
- A 1990 review by Hewstone found a preference for in-group-serving over out-group-serving attributions.