Answer the following questions in about 150 words each :
(d) How does the critical period hypothesis support the idea of biological predisposition?
10 marks · answer in 150 words · directive: Explain
The core of a good answer
The critical period hypothesis holds that some capacities, notably language, develop normally only if the right experience occurs within a biologically timed window; such a maturationally fixed window implies that the brain is pre-wired to learn certain things at certain ages, which is the essence of biological predisposition.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
Explain the hypothesis and then show the link to biology: timing set by maturation, evidence from animals and from language deprivation, and a note that later evidence favours softer sensitive periods.
Answer outline
Introduction
Eric Lenneberg, in Biological Foundations of Language (1967), argued that language is learned normally only between early childhood and about puberty, tying the end of the period to the lateralisation of brain functions.
How it supports biological predisposition
- The window is set by maturation, not by teaching, which points to an innate programme.
- Chomsky's language acquisition device: innate principles let children construct grammar from limited input; a timed window fits such an inborn device.
- Neural plasticity is greatest early and declines, consistent with a biologically scheduled readiness.
Evidence
- Imprinting: Lorenz found geese imprinted within a critical period of roughly 13 to 16 hours after hatching.
- Vision: early visual deprivation in animals produces lasting deficits.
- Genie, discovered at age 13 after extreme isolation, never gained full grammatical competence despite years of help.
- Newport and Supalla found that performance in American Sign Language declined steadily with the age at which deaf children were first exposed to it.
Qualification
- Decline in learning is often gradual, so many prefer the term sensitive period; environment still decides what is learned.
Conclusion
The hypothesis shows that nature sets the timetable while nurture supplies the content: predisposition and experience work together.
Examples and data to cite
- Genie (Los Angeles), found at about 13 after being confined from about 20 months of age.
- Lorenz's goslings followed him as their first moving object.
Facts to remember
- Lenneberg's Biological Foundations of Language appeared in 1967.
- A critical period is a fixed window; a sensitive period is a time of heightened but not exclusive readiness.
- Lenneberg linked the end of the period to completion of lateralisation around puberty.