What kind of heuristics is used by the people while making decisions? Also, discuss the errors and biases in group decision making.
15 marks · directive: Discuss
The core of a good answer
People rely on mental shortcuts such as availability, representativeness, anchoring and adjustment, affect and recognition, which are usually efficient but produce predictable biases; groups add their own errors, including groupthink and group polarisation, which structured procedures can reduce.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
Two parts: identify and illustrate decision heuristics; then discuss errors and biases specific to group decisions with evidence, ideally with remedies.
Answer outline
Introduction
Heuristics are rules of thumb that simplify judgement under uncertainty. Herbert Simon's idea of bounded rationality and satisficing explains why people use them: limited time, information and cognitive capacity.
Heuristics in individual decisions
- Availability: judging frequency by ease of recall; people think more English words begin with K than have K in third place, though the reverse is true.
- Representativeness: judging probability by resemblance, ignoring base rates; the Linda problem produces the conjunction fallacy.
- Anchoring and adjustment: estimates stay close to an initial, even irrelevant, number.
- Affect heuristic: judging risks and benefits by feelings.
- Recognition and fast-and-frugal heuristics (Gigerenzer) can be accurate in the right environment.
Errors and biases in group decisions
- Groupthink (Irving Janis): cohesive groups under stress seek consensus, with illusions of invulnerability and unanimity, self-censorship and mindguards; examples include the Bay of Pigs (1961) and Challenger (1986).
- Group polarisation: discussion pushes members to more extreme versions of their initial views (the risky shift).
Remedies
- Devil's advocate or critical evaluator, leader withholding opinions, independent subgroups and outside experts.
Conclusion
Heuristics are adaptive tools, and groups can outperform individuals, but only when procedures deliberately counter shared biases.
Examples and data to cite
- Tversky and Kahneman's 1974 Science paper on judgement under uncertainty described availability, representativeness and anchoring.
- Janis analysed the 1961 Bay of Pigs decision as groupthink.
Facts to remember
- Satisficing means choosing the first option that meets an aspiration level.
- Janis listed eight symptoms of groupthink.
- A conjunction cannot be more probable than either of its parts.