Does IQ predict mental retardation? Explain the classification of mental retardation with regard to IQ scores given by Stanford-Binet.
15 marks · directive: Explain
The core of a good answer
IQ is a necessary but not a sufficient indicator: an IQ about two standard deviations below the mean (around 70 or below) signals significantly sub-average intellectual functioning, but mental retardation, now called intellectual disability, is diagnosed only with deficits in adaptive behaviour beginning in the developmental period; the Stanford-Binet labels IQ 69 and below as mentally defective (1937 and 1960 revisions) and the fifth edition grades mild (55 to 69) and moderate (40 to 54) impairment, while standard-deviation bands of the AAMD kind extend the grading to severe and profound.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
Two tasks: evaluate whether IQ alone predicts or defines mental retardation, and explain the IQ-based classification linked to the Stanford-Binet, with the ranges. Note the change in terminology and in the role of IQ.
Answer outline
Introduction
The AAMD definition (Classification in Mental Retardation, 1983) states that mental retardation refers to significantly subaverage general intellectual functioning existing concurrently with deficits in adaptive behaviour and manifested during the developmental period. DSM-5 (2013) uses the term intellectual disability, and ICD-11 uses disorders of intellectual development.
Does IQ predict it?
- Yes in part: people with intellectual disability generally have IQs below about 70, two standard deviations below the mean, which covers about 2.28% of a normal distribution.
- No on its own: adaptive behaviour (such as communication, self-help and interpersonal skills) must also be limited, and onset must be in the developmental period.
- DSM-5 sets severity on the basis of adaptive functioning, not IQ scores; the AAMD (1983) treats IQ 70 only as a guideline that could be extended to 75 or more depending on the reliability of the test used.
Stanford-Binet classifications
- Terman's 1916 Stanford-Binet: IQ 69 and below 'definite feeble-mindedness'; 70 to 80 borderline deficiency.
- 1937 and 1960 (Form L-M) revisions: 69 and below 'mentally defective'; 70 to 79 'borderline defective'; Form L-M used a standard deviation of 16.
- Applying the same standard-deviation steps to Form L-M (SD 16) gives, by arithmetic, mild 52 to 67, moderate 36 to 51, severe 20 to 35 and profound below 20; the AAMD manual says only that its ranges vary slightly on a scale with an SD of 16, as on the Stanford-Binet.
- With SD 15 (Wechsler-type scales, as in the 1977 AAMD manual; SB5 also uses SD 15): mild 55 to 69, moderate 40 to 54, severe 25 to 39, profound below 25.
- SB5 (2003) labels: 70 to 79 borderline impaired or delayed, 55 to 69 mildly impaired or delayed, 40 to 54 moderately impaired or delayed.
Distribution and needs
- About 85% of people with intellectual disability are in the mild range; they can learn reading and mathematics, and many live independently and work; people with moderate disability need considerable support.
Conclusion
IQ identifies intellectual limitation, but a valid diagnosis and plan of support depend on adaptive functioning, which is why DSM-5 grades severity by adaptive functioning.
Examples and data to cite
- AAMD manual (Grossman, 1983): mild 50 to 55 to about 70, moderate 35 to 40 to 50 to 55, severe 20 to 25 to 35 to 40, profound below 20 or 25, with overlapping ranges and clinical judgement.
Facts to remember
- Stanford-Binet bands (SD 16), computed as 2, 3, 4 and 5 SD below 100: cut points 68, 52, 36 and 20.
- Wechsler and SB5 use a standard deviation of 15; cut points 70, 55, 40 and 25.
- About 2.28% of a normal distribution lies more than 2 SD below the mean.