Compare and contrast psychodynamic, behavioural and cognitive therapies. Which is more effective in modern clinical practice ?
15 marks · directive: Compare and contrast
The core of a good answer
Psychodynamic therapy seeks insight into unconscious conflict through the therapeutic relationship, behaviour therapy changes maladaptive behaviour through learning principles, and cognitive therapy changes distorted thinking; cognitive behavioural therapy has strong evidence, with its largest effects for anxiety disorders, but meta-analyses show bona fide therapies differ little overall, so effectiveness depends on the disorder, the client and the therapeutic alliance.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
Compare the three on assumptions, goals, techniques, therapist role and duration, then answer the evaluative second part with evidence (Smith and Glass, the dodo bird debate, CBT evidence) rather than opinion.
Answer outline
Introduction
Psychotherapies differ in what they treat as the cause of distress: unconscious conflict (psychodynamic), learned behaviour (behavioural) or faulty cognition (cognitive). Smith and Glass (1977) showed that, overall, the typical therapy client is better off than 75% of untreated individuals.
Psychodynamic therapy
- Assumption: symptoms express unresolved unconscious conflicts rooted in early experience.
- Techniques: free association, dream interpretation, analysis of resistance, transference and counter-transference.
- Goal: insight and personality change; longer, less structured; brief dynamic forms now exist.
Behaviour therapy
- Assumption: maladaptive behaviour is learned and can be unlearned.
- Techniques: Wolpe's systematic desensitisation (developed in the 1950s) through an anxiety hierarchy, relaxation and counter-conditioning; exposure, which is particularly effective for many specific phobias.
- Goal: symptom and behaviour change; structured, short and measurable.
Cognitive therapy
- Assumption: emotions follow interpretations; distorted thinking maintains disorder.
- Beck's cognitive therapy (Depression: Causes and Treatment, 1967): the negative triad about self, world and future, and underlying schemas.
- Albert Ellis worked on cognitive treatment from the 1950s, later calling his approach rational emotive behaviour therapy.
- Techniques: cognitive restructuring through Socratic questioning; structured and directive.
Comparison
- Focus: past and unconscious (psychodynamic) versus present behaviour and thoughts (behavioural, cognitive).
- Therapist role: interpretive and relatively neutral versus active, directive, collaborative.
- Evidence: behavioural and cognitive methods are easier to test in trials; psychodynamic research has grown, with meta-analyses finding it effective.
Which is more effective?
- Dodo bird verdict (Rosenzweig 1936; Luborsky, Singer and Luborsky 1975): few overall differences between bona fide therapies; common factors such as the alliance matter.
- Specific effects exist: CBT is reported to give superior results, with the largest effects for anxiety disorders.
- A 2017 meta-analysis found psychodynamic therapy as efficacious as other therapies including CBT, and long-term psychoanalytic therapy may give small but significant benefits for complex mental disorders.
- Modern practice is evidence-based and often integrative, matching the therapy to the problem and to client preference; common factors such as the alliance account for much of the outcome.
Conclusion
CBT has strong research support today, but no single therapy is best for everyone; the right question is which therapy, by whom, for which problem.
Examples and data to cite
- Smith and Glass (1977): 375 studies, average effect size 0.68; typical client better off than 75% of untreated people.
- Wolpe, Psychotherapy by Reciprocal Inhibition (1958), systematic desensitisation.
Facts to remember
- Rosenzweig (1936) coined the dodo bird verdict: 'Everybody has won and all must have prizes'.
- Beck's negative cognitive triad: negative views of self, world and future.
- Reported CBT effect sizes: 0.51 for generalised anxiety disorder and 0.62 for social anxiety disorder.