How do biological, psychological and social factors influence mental disorders ? Critically examine the concept of mental health and well-being.
20 marks · directive: Explain; Critically examine
The core of a good answer
Mental disorders arise from interacting biological (genes, brain circuits, neurochemistry), psychological (cognitions, coping, early attachment, personality) and social (poverty, adversity, discrimination, support) factors, as Engel's biopsychosocial model and the vulnerability-stress model hold; mental health is more than the absence of disorder, as the WHO definition and Keyes's flourishing model show, but definitions of well-being are value-laden and culturally variable.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
Part one needs the three sets of factors with examples and an integrating model. Part two asks for a critical examination: definitions (WHO, Jahoda-type positive criteria, hedonic and eudaimonic well-being, Keyes), their strengths and their limits.
Answer outline
Introduction
Engel's 1977 paper in Science argued that biology alone cannot explain illness; health and illness result from the interaction of biological, psychological and social factors.
Biological factors
- Genetic vulnerability: WHO lists genetics among individual risk factors; for anxiety disorders the overall genetic contribution is put at 30 to 50%.
- Brain circuits and neurotransmitters: for example, increased amygdala blood flow in anxiety and the anxiolytic action of drugs on GABA-A receptors.
- Substance use, which WHO lists among individual factors.
Psychological factors
- Negative cognitive schemas (Beck) and weak emotional skills.
- Child abuse and poor attachment.
Social factors
- Poverty, violence, inequality and environmental deprivation raise risk (WHO).
- Income inequality and unemployment are strongly associated with poor mental health, and adolescents with fewer peer and parental supports and more loneliness are at higher risk.
- Vulnerability-stress (diathesis-stress) model: a disorder develops when the combination of predisposition and stress exceeds a threshold.
Concept of mental health and well-being
- WHO: mental health is a state of mental well-being that enables people to cope with the stresses of life, realise their abilities, learn and work well, and contribute to their community; it exists on a continuum.
- Hedonic well-being: positive feelings and life satisfaction. Eudaimonic well-being: Ryff's six dimensions of self-acceptance, personal growth, purpose in life, environmental mastery, autonomy and positive relations.
- Keyes (2002): flourishing combines high emotional, psychological and social well-being; languishing is its opposite, so absence of illness is not the same as health.
- Seligman's PERMA (2011): positive emotion, engagement, relationships, meaning and accomplishment.
Critical examination
- Mental health is a socially constructed concept: norms of 'adjustment' can pathologise dissent or cultural difference.
- Cultures, groups and professions conceptualise the nature and causes of mental health very differently, so one standard cannot be assumed.
- Positive psychology measures can miss morality: someone may score well on PERMA yet harm others.
- Focus on individual well-being can hide structural causes such as poverty; the biopsychosocial model is also criticised for 'undisciplined eclecticism' and lack of philosophical coherence.
- Still, the positive view supports promotion and prevention, not only treatment.
Conclusion
Mental disorder is best understood as a biopsychosocial outcome, and mental health as positive, culturally situated functioning; policy must address both individual vulnerability and social conditions.
Examples and data to cite
- NMHS 2015-16 (India): 10.6% of adults had a current mental disorder; treatment gap 70% to 92%.
- Engel (1977), 'The need for a new medical model: a challenge for biomedicine', Science.
Facts to remember
- WHO lists individual factors (emotional skills, substance use, genetics) and social and environmental factors (poverty, violence, inequality, environmental deprivation) as determinants of mental health.
- Keyes's Mental Health Continuum-Short Form (2002) has 14 items rated from 0 to 5 over the past four weeks.
- Ryff's six dimensions of psychological well-being.