Different paradigms of public administration deal with the questions of ‘How’ and ‘Why’, but do not negate the centrality of the discipline. Discuss.
20 marks · directive: Discuss
The core of a good answer
From the politics-administration dichotomy and the principles school to the behavioural, New Public Administration, New Public Management and governance paradigms, each has shifted the focus between how to administer efficiently and why administration exists and for whom; these shifts have redefined the field's locus and focus, but none has removed the central concern with public action in the public interest.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
Discuss requires a survey of the paradigms and an argument. In the first half show how each paradigm answers 'how' (techniques, structures) and 'why' (values, purposes). In the second half argue that, despite the identity crisis, the discipline keeps a central and distinctive core.
Answer outline
Introduction
The development of public administration can be traced through successive paradigms, each giving a different answer to what the field should study and why.
Paradigms that stressed 'How'
- Woodrow Wilson's The Study of Administration (1887) separated politics from administration and asked how government can act efficiently.
- Principles school: Luther Gulick's POSDCORB (planning, organising, staffing, directing, coordinating, reporting, budgeting) sought universal principles.
- Scientific management and later New Public Management (Hood 1991) emphasised performance, competition and managerial techniques.
Paradigms that stressed 'Why'
- Herbert Simon's Administrative Behavior (1947) and the behavioural school asked why administrators decide as they do, through bounded rationality.
- Minnowbrook Conference (1968), led by Dwight Waldo, produced the New Public Administration, focused on relevance, values, equity and change.
- New Public Service (Janet and Robert Denhardt) and governance approaches asked why and for whom the state acts, stressing citizenship and public value.
Centrality of the discipline
- Every paradigm still studies the organisation and management of public action; only emphasis shifts between efficiency and values.
- The identity crisis (whether it can properly be called a discipline or is a sub-field of political science) has been resolved in practice by its expanding scope: policy, governance, development, ethics.
- Administration remains the state in action; no public goal, from welfare to regulation, is achieved without it.
Conclusion
Paradigms answer different questions at different times, and that pluralism is a sign of a living discipline whose centrality grows with the functions of the state.
Examples and data to cite
- Woodrow Wilson, The Study of Administration (1887).
- Minnowbrook Conference 1968 and the New Public Administration.
- Christopher Hood (1991), who set out the basic aspects of New Public Management.
- Dunleavy and others, New Public Management is Dead: Long Live Digital-Era Governance (2006).
Facts to remember
- POSDCORB stands for planning, organising, staffing, directing, coordinating, reporting and budgeting.
- Simon's Administrative Behavior was first published in 1947.