The fine demarcation between judicial control and judicial overreach disappears when judicial prudence is replaced by activism. Critically examine.
15 marks · directive: Critically examine
The core of a good answer
Judicial control of administration (review for legality, rationality, procedural fairness and rights) is a constitutional duty; it turns into overreach when courts substitute their own policy choices, run administration through continuing directions or legislate in the absence of law, so restraint and respect for the separation of powers are what keep control legitimate.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
Critically examine needs both sides. Define judicial control and its grounds (5 marks); then examine where activism has strengthened accountability and where it has become overreach, ending with a balanced view (10 marks).
Answer outline
Introduction
Judicial control is one of the classic external controls over administration, exercised through writs under Articles 32 and 226 and through review of administrative and legislative action.
Legitimate control
- Review for illegality, irrationality and procedural impropriety; enforcement of fundamental rights.
- Public interest litigation widened access: Hussainara Khatoon (petition filed in 1979) led to free legal aid and speedy trial for undertrial prisoners.
- Vishaka (1997) filled a legislative vacuum with guidelines on sexual harassment, later replaced by the POSH Act, 2013.
Where activism becomes overreach
- Courts issuing detailed administrative directions (for example converting Delhi auto-rickshaws to CNG, closing mining) step into executive domains.
- Frivolous PILs and busybody petitions; a 2005 report described PIL as having become an industry.
- Parliament has amended the Constitution in response to rulings; in 2008 the Prime Minister said PILs may have gone too far.
- Overreach can weaken executive accountability, because courts are not answerable to the electorate.
Judicial prudence
- Presumption of constitutionality, deference on policy and technical matters, self-restraint, and dismissing frivolous petitions with costs.
- Directions only to fill genuine gaps and only until legislation or executive action follows.
Conclusion
Activism is defensible as a corrective when other institutions fail; it becomes overreach when it replaces them. Prudence keeps the line visible.
Examples and data to cite
- Hussainara Khatoon v. State of Bihar: a petition on Bihar undertrial prisoners led to orders for free legal aid and speedy hearings; about 40,000 prisoners were released.
- Supreme Court Advocates-on-Record Association v. Union of India (16 October 2015) struck down the NJAC, a decision debated as judicial supremacy.
- Justice S.H. Kapadia warned that litigants filing frivolous PILs would face substantial fines.
Facts to remember
- Writ jurisdiction: Article 32 (Supreme Court) and Article 226 (High Courts).
- The basic structure doctrine bars Parliament from abrogating the rule of law even by constitutional amendment.