Examine the tension between the functional efficiency of delegated legislation and the risks it poses to accountability and the rule of law.
15 marks · directive: Examine
The core of a good answer
Delegated legislation is indispensable because legislatures cannot foresee technical detail and change, and rules made by the executive allow speed, flexibility and expertise; but it shifts law-making to unelected officials and can escape scrutiny, so its legitimacy rests on limits on what may be delegated, parliamentary oversight and judicial review.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
Examine requires analysis of both sides: the efficiency argument (5 marks) and the risks with safeguards (10 marks). Use Indian practice and the classic British debate.
Answer outline
Introduction
Delegated (subordinate) legislation is law made by the executive under powers given by a parent Act; the statute sets principles and leaves detail to rules, regulations, notifications and orders.
Functional efficiency
- Pressure on legislative time and the technical nature of modern regulation.
- Flexibility to adjust to changing circumstances and emergencies without fresh legislation.
- Use of expertise and consultation with affected interests; experiment with pilot rules.
Risks to accountability and rule of law
- Lord Hewart's The New Despotism (1929) argued that the rule of law was being undermined by the executive at the expense of the legislature and the courts; the controversy led to the Committee on Ministers' Powers chaired by the Earl of Donoughmore.
- Excessive delegation can transfer essential policy choices away from the legislature.
- Rules may be framed with little publicity or consultation, and laying before the House is often a formality.
- Henry VIII clauses, which allow primary legislation to be amended by secondary legislation, are seen by some as weakening Parliament's supremacy.
Safeguards
- Parliamentary control: laying of rules, the Committee on Subordinate Legislation (15 nominated members).
- Judicial review of the validity of secondary legislation.
- Pre-legislative consultation and publication.
Conclusion
The tension is managed, not removed: efficiency is acceptable only within a framework of clear statutory policy, real parliamentary scrutiny and judicial review.
Examples and data to cite
- Hewart, The New Despotism (1929) and the Donoughmore Committee on Ministers' Powers, which rejected Hewart's arguments.
- Australia: secondary legislation can be disallowed by a resolution of either House of Parliament.
Facts to remember
- India's Committee on Subordinate Legislation has 15 nominated members with a one-year tenure.
- Secondary legislation is made by an executive authority under powers delegated by primary legislation, and its validity can be reviewed by a court.