Answer the following in about 150 words each :
(d) Linkages between the district administration and local self governments have not evolved to the desired extent. Evaluate.
10 marks · answer in 150 words · directive: Evaluate
The core of a good answer
Three decades after the 73rd and 74th Amendments, the Collector-led district administration and elected panchayats and municipalities still work largely in parallel: District Planning Committees are weak, functions, funds and functionaries are only partly devolved, and line departments report upward to the state rather than to local bodies; yet convergence has improved in some programmes.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
"Evaluate" requires a judgement on how far the statement is true. Set out where the linkages were meant to exist, show the gaps with evidence, note the progress, and end with a balanced verdict.
Answer outline
Introduction
The 73rd Amendment (in force 24 April 1993) and 74th Amendment created constitutional local governments, while the district administration under the Collector remained the State's principal field agency.
Intended linkages
- Article 243ZD: a District Planning Committee in every district to consolidate panchayat and municipal plans into a draft district development plan.
- Article 243G with the Eleventh Schedule (29 subjects) and Article 243W with the Twelfth Schedule (18 subjects) for devolution of functions.
- State Finance Commissions (Article 243I) to link local finances with the state.
Why linkages remain weak
- Devolution of functions, funds and functionaries is uneven; staff of line departments remain under state control.
- District Planning Committees are weak, so district plans remain departmental.
- The Collector chairs many district bodies and programmes, which keeps elected heads in a secondary role.
- Parallel bodies and scheme-specific societies bypass panchayats.
Signs of progress
- 21 states and two Union Territories have raised the reservation of panchayat seats for women to 50 per cent.
Conclusion
The framework for linkage exists; what is missing is the political and administrative will to make district administration a facilitator of local governments rather than a parallel authority.
Examples and data to cite
- Second Administrative Reforms Commission, Sixth Report "Local Governance" (2007).
Facts to remember
- Part IX (Articles 243 to 243O) and the Eleventh Schedule were added by the 73rd Amendment.
- The 73rd Amendment provides for State Election Commissions and State Finance Commissions.
- The 73rd Amendment mandates a three-tier panchayat system with elections every five years; the intermediate tier may be omitted in a state with population not exceeding 20 lakh.