Government of India has done Corporatisation of Ordnance Factory Boards. Discuss the rationale in the light of Disinvestment Policy of the government.
20 marks · directive: Discuss
The core of a good answer
The 41 ordnance factories, run departmentally by the Ordnance Factory Board, were corporatised into seven wholly government-owned defence companies from 1 October 2021 to improve autonomy, accountability and efficiency; this fits the 2021 New PSE Policy, under which sectors chosen on criteria such as national security keep a bare minimum public presence, so corporatisation is a step towards commercial discipline rather than privatisation.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
The question asks for the reasons behind corporatisation and how they relate to the government's disinvestment policy. Explain the problems of the old model, the reform, its link to strategic sector policy, and the concerns raised.
Answer outline
Introduction
The Ordnance Factory Board ran factories as a department of the Ministry of Defence. The government ordered its dissolution from 1 October 2021 and transferred assets, employees and management to seven new Defence Public Sector Undertakings.
Problems of the departmental model
- Committees since 2004 had recommended restructuring; the factories were criticised for poor quality products, delays in delivery and slow technological progress.
- Lack of financial and managerial autonomy and blurred accountability for performance.
Rationale of corporatisation
- Autonomy, accountability and efficiency of ordnance supplies, with each company answerable for its own results.
- Specialisation by product line: munitions, armoured vehicles, weapons, troop comfort items, engineering, optics and parachutes.
- Ability to access markets, including exports, and diversify products.
Link with disinvestment policy
- The New PSE Policy (4 February 2021) keeps a bare minimum presence of public enterprises in strategic sectors chosen on criteria such as national security.
- Corporatisation is not privatisation: the seven companies are wholly owned by the government, but the company form keeps later options open.
- It follows the policy's logic of separating the government as owner from management.
Concerns
- Opposition from employee unions over service conditions; restructuring attempts in 2014 had been resisted.
- Viability of weaker units.
- Need for a level playing field with private defence firms.
Conclusion
Corporatisation is a governance reform within a strategic sector: it uses the company form to bring commercial discipline while keeping ownership with the State, consistent with but distinct from disinvestment.
Examples and data to cite
- Seven companies: Munitions India Limited, Armoured Vehicles Nigam Limited, Advanced Weapons and Equipment India Limited, Troop Comforts Limited, Yantra India Limited, India Optel Limited and Gliders India Limited.
- Department of Public Enterprises guidelines (13 December 2021) operationalised the New PSE Policy.
Facts to remember
- 41 ordnance factories were subsumed into seven companies.
- Strategic sectors under the New PSE Policy are identified using five criteria: national security, energy security, critical infrastructure, financial services and important minerals.
- In non-strategic sectors, PSEs are to be privatised where feasible, otherwise closed.