Competitive federalism in India while intended to have healthy competition among states has shown tendencies towards parochialism. Comment.
10 marks · directive: Comment
The core of a good answer
Competitive federalism was meant to make states compete for investment, better governance and outcomes through rankings and reform incentives; it has produced reform and innovation, but it has also encouraged parochial measures such as local job quotas, incentive races that favour richer states and inter-state friction, so it needs a cooperative frame and national market rules.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
"Comment" asks for a view with reasons. Explain the idea, show its healthy outcomes, then the parochial tendencies with examples, and suggest how to keep competition healthy.
Answer outline
Introduction
Competitive federalism is the idea that states compete with one another and with other countries for capital, talent and better governance outcomes.
Intended healthy competition
- Ranking of states and cities on governance and outcome indices spurs reform.
- States reform land, labour and approvals to attract investment and hold investor summits.
Parochial tendencies
- Domicile quotas for local residents in private jobs, which sit uneasily with the rights of citizens under Articles 16 and 19.
- Races to give tax concessions and subsidies erode revenue and favour states with better infrastructure.
- Disputes over water, projects and investment shifting across state borders.
- Richer states pull ahead, widening regional inequality.
Making it healthy
- Combine with cooperative platforms such as the GST Council and NITI's Governing Council.
- Use Finance Commission criteria to reward performance while protecting weaker states.
- Articles 14, 16 and 19 limit discrimination against citizens of other states.
Conclusion
Competition works only within a common national market and constitutional citizenship; otherwise it slides into parochialism.
Examples and data to cite
- Ease of Living Index 2020, released on 4 March 2021, ranked 111 cities, an instance of competition through rankings.
Facts to remember
- NITI Aayog aims to foster cooperative federalism and move away from bargaining federalism.
- Article 16(3) allows only Parliament to prescribe residence requirements for public employment.
- Article 19(1)(e) and (g) guarantee the right to reside and practise any profession throughout India.