Trace the reasons for growing incidences of disagreements between the Governors and state governments.
10 marks · directive: Trace
The core of a good answer
Disagreements between Governors and state governments have grown because of the Governor's dual role as constitutional head and Union appointee, vague discretion under Articles 163 and 200, political appointments, divergence between parties ruling at the Centre and in states, delays on Bills and appointments, and the absence of time limits, leading to repeated litigation that reached the Supreme Court in 2025.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
"Trace" asks you to follow the causes from their roots to present events. List structural, political and legal reasons with examples, and end with recommended correctives.
Answer outline
Introduction
Under Article 153 every state has a Governor, appointed by the President (Article 155) and holding office during the pleasure of the President (Article 156); Article 163 requires him to act on ministerial advice except where the Constitution requires discretion.
Structural reasons
- Dual role: constitutional head of the state and link with the Union, which invites partisan use.
- Tenure at pleasure (Article 156) allows removal of Governors with a change at the Centre.
- Undefined discretion over Bills (Article 200), government formation and reporting under Article 356.
Political reasons
- Appointment of persons with active political backgrounds.
- Different parties ruling at the Centre and in opposition-ruled states.
- Disputes over vice-chancellor appointments, summoning of the House and addresses to the Assembly.
Legal flashpoints
- State of Tamil Nadu v. Governor of Tamil Nadu (8 April 2025): indefinite withholding of assent was illegal; timelines were set and assent to ten Bills deemed under Article 142.
- Presidential reference opinion (20 November 2025, five judges): courts cannot fix timelines or deem assent, but prolonged, unexplained inaction invites a limited mandamus.
Conclusion
Disagreements are rooted in design and politics; conventions of restraint, Sarkaria Commission recommendations, and limited judicial review are the way to restore the office's neutral role.
Examples and data to cite
- President Droupadi Murmu made a reference under Article 143 on 13 May 2025, posing 14 questions on Articles 200 and 201.
- Sarkaria Commission (set up 1983, report 1988) made 247 recommendations on Centre-state relations.
Facts to remember
- Under Article 200 the Governor may assent, withhold assent or reserve a Bill for the President; a withheld Bill must be returned to the Assembly under the first proviso.
- The 2025 opinion held that Article 142 cannot be used to substitute the Governor's or President's powers.
- Article 361(1): the Governor is not answerable to any court for the exercise and performance of the powers and duties of the office.