Answer the following in about 150 words each :
(b) Though seldom enacted, Cut Motions remain vital instruments of parliamentary accountability. Comment.
10 marks · answer in 150 words · directive: Comment
The core of a good answer
Cut motions on demands for grants almost never pass because the government commands a majority in the Lok Sabha, but they remain valuable because they force debate on specific policies, expenditure and grievances, put the opposition's critique on record and test the government's majority.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
"Comment" asks for a view: explain the device and its types, why they rarely succeed, and why they still matter for accountability. Add how their value is diluted in practice.
Answer outline
Introduction
Cut motions are moved under Rule 209 of the Lok Sabha Rules of Procedure to reduce the amount of a demand for grants during the budget process (Article 113).
Types under Rule 209
- Disapproval of policy cut: demand be reduced to Re 1, expressing disapproval of the policy underlying it.
- Economy cut: reduction by a specified amount representing the economy that can be effected.
- Token cut: demand be reduced by Rs 100 to ventilate a specific grievance within the responsibility of the Government of India.
Why seldom adopted
- The government commands a majority in the Lok Sabha, so a cut motion rarely succeeds.
Why they remain vital
- They focus debate on specific ministries, schemes and spending rather than general criticism.
- They record dissent and test the government's numbers.
- Token cuts allow members to raise constituency and sectoral grievances.
Conclusion
Their power lies in deliberation, not in passage; strengthening budget scrutiny time and committee work would restore their value.
Facts to remember
- Article 113(2): estimates of expenditure not charged on the Consolidated Fund are submitted as demands for grants, and the Lok Sabha may assent, refuse or reduce them.
- Rule 209(a) uses the words "that the amount of the demand be reduced to Re. 1/-"; Rule 209(c) "reduced by Rs. 100/-".
- Article 113(2) gives the power to assent to, refuse or reduce demands for grants to the House of the People (Lok Sabha) alone.