Answer the following in about 150 words each :
(c) Administrative reforms in India have been a double-edged sword. Comment.
10 marks · answer in 150 words · directive: Comment
The core of a good answer
Administrative reforms in India have improved efficiency, transparency and service delivery, as in digital delivery, direct benefit transfers and the Right to Information, but the same reforms have produced unintended effects such as exclusion, centralisation, weakened accountability or resistance, because they were often partial, top-down or poorly sequenced.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
"Comment" asks for a reasoned view. Show the benefits and the costs of major reforms with examples, and conclude with what makes reform beneficial rather than harmful.
Answer outline
Introduction
Administrative reform means deliberate changes in structures, processes and personnel of government to improve performance; India has had two Administrative Reforms Commissions (1966 and 2005) and many programme-level reforms.
The positive edge
- The Right to Information Act improved transparency and citizen power.
- Direct Benefit Transfer and digital public infrastructure reduced leakages and intermediaries.
- Online procurement and e-governance cut discretion; Mission Karmayogi focuses on competencies.
The negative edge
- Digital reforms can exclude people without connectivity or with authentication failures.
- Centralised dashboards and schemes can weaken local governments and states.
- Corporatisation and contracting can dilute accountability to legislatures.
- Partial reforms create new rigidities, for example lateral entry without reservation led to cancellation in 2024.
- Reforms imposed without consultation face resistance from staff and unions.
What makes the difference
- Consultation, pilots, grievance redress and evaluation; protection for the vulnerable.
Conclusion
Reform is a tool whose edge depends on design; citizen-centred, evidence-based and participatory reform cuts in the right direction.
Examples and data to cite
- Ordnance factory corporatisation (2021) raised union protests about service conditions.
Facts to remember
- The Second Administrative Reforms Commission submitted 15 reports between 2006 and 2009.
- Mission Karmayogi covers about 46 lakh central government employees.