Public debt of states in India has increased significantly in the last one decade. In this context discuss the constraints of the states in planning prudent fiscal management.
20 marks · directive: Discuss
The core of a good answer
States' outstanding liabilities rose from 25.3 per cent of GDP at end-March 2019 to 31.0 per cent at end-March 2021 and were 28.5 per cent at end-March 2024; prudent fiscal management is constrained by a narrow own tax base after GST, dependence on transfers, high committed expenditure, competitive subsidies and pension commitments, off-budget borrowing, borrowing limits under Article 293 and weak capacity for fiscal planning.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
"Discuss" asks you to set the debt trend in context and then examine the constraints in detail, ending with ways forward.
Answer outline
Introduction
State debt matters because states carry most expenditure on health, education, police and agriculture. The RBI's State Finances study for 2024-25 (released 19 December 2024) found that liabilities have declined from the pandemic peak but remain above pre-pandemic levels.
Debt trend
- Outstanding liabilities: 25.3 per cent of GDP (end-March 2019), 31.0 per cent (end-March 2021), 28.5 per cent (end-March 2024).
- Consolidated gross fiscal deficit was kept within 3 per cent of GDP in 2022-23 and 2023-24; budgeted 3.2 per cent for 2024-25.
- The RBI flagged contingent liabilities and rising subsidies as concerns.
Revenue constraints
- GST pooled most indirect taxes, limiting states' autonomy to raise revenue.
- Dependence on Finance Commission devolution and centrally sponsored schemes with matching shares.
Expenditure constraints
- Committed expenditure on salaries, pensions and interest leaves little room for capital spending.
- Competitive populism: free power, cash transfers and loan waivers.
Institutional constraints
- Article 293(3): states indebted to the Centre need its consent to borrow, which gives the Centre control over borrowing limits.
- Off-budget borrowings through state entities add to liabilities outside the budget.
- Guarantees to state enterprises such as power distribution companies create hidden debt.
- Weak medium-term fiscal frameworks, outcome budgeting and data transparency.
Way forward
- Better reporting of guarantees and off-budget borrowings, as the RBI urged.
- Own revenue mobilisation (property tax, user charges), subsidy rationalisation and power sector reform.
- Independent state fiscal councils and credible FRBM laws.
Conclusion
State debt is a structural, not cyclical, problem; prudent management needs both state discipline and a cooperative fiscal framework that gives states predictable resources.
Examples and data to cite
- RBI, State Finances: A Study of Budgets of 2024-25 (19 December 2024).
- Fifteenth Finance Commission (chair N.K. Singh) covered 2021-22 to 2025-26; its final report was tabled on 1 February 2021.
Facts to remember
- Article 293(1): a state may borrow within India on the security of its Consolidated Fund within limits fixed by its Legislature.
- Article 293(3): consent of the Government of India is needed while any part of a loan from the Centre is outstanding.