Compare and critically assess ‘the grounded theory’ with ‘theory-driven research method’ in sociology.
20 marks · directive: Compare and critically assess
The core of a good answer
Theory-driven (deductive) research begins with existing theory, derives hypotheses and tests them with data, while grounded theory (Glaser and Strauss, 1967) builds theory inductively from data through coding, constant comparison and theoretical sampling; the first is strong on testing and generalisation, the second on discovery and fit with lived reality, and the best research moves between them.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
Compare the two on logic, starting point, role of literature, sampling, analysis and outcomes, then assess the strengths and weaknesses of each and conclude on their complementarity.
Answer outline
Introduction
The two approaches differ mainly in where theory comes from: before the data (deduction) or out of the data (induction).
Theory-driven research
- Steps: theory, hypothesis, operationalisation, data collection, testing, acceptance or rejection.
- Linked to Popper's falsifiability (1934).
- Strengths: cumulative knowledge, generalisation, replicability; typical of survey and experimental research.
- Weaknesses: may force data into prior categories; Mills criticised grand theory as detached from history and observation.
Grounded theory
- Developed by Barney Glaser and Anselm Strauss from their studies of dying hospital patients (Awareness of Dying, 1965; The Discovery of Grounded Theory, 1967).
- Procedures: open coding, constant comparison, theoretical sampling, memo writing, selective coding around a core category that explains how participants handle their main concern.
- Later split: Strauss and Corbin (1990) introduced axial coding; Glaser (1992) defended emergence; Kathy Charmaz developed constructivist grounded theory.
- Strengths: discovery of new concepts close to participants' meanings; useful in unexplored fields.
Critical assessment
- Grounded theory is criticised as too empiricist, as assuming preconception-free research is possible, and for formulaic terminology and weak generalisation.
- Theoretical sampling in grounded theory itself has a deductive element; Merton's middle-range theory aims to integrate theory with empirical research.
Conclusion
The two are complementary phases of one research cycle: grounded theory generates concepts that theory-driven research can then test.
Examples and data to cite
- Glaser and Strauss's hospital studies of dying patients.
- Merton's middle-range theory as an attempt to integrate theory and research.
Facts to remember
- The Discovery of Grounded Theory was published in 1967.
- Axial coding was proposed by Strauss and Corbin in 1990.
- Popper introduced falsifiability in 1934.