Indological approach, advocated by G. S. Ghurye, focuses on the study of Indian society through Indian texts. How can Indological approach be useful in the study of other society? Comment in detail.
20 marks · directive: Comment
The core of a good answer
The Indological method of reading a society through its classical texts, myths, law books and art, which Ghurye combined with history and comparison, is useful for any society with a long literate tradition because texts reveal its values, institutions and their history; it works best when checked against field data, since texts often record the ideal of elites rather than everyday practice.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
Comment asks for an opinion backed by reasons. Explain the Indological approach and Ghurye's use of it, then show how it can be applied to other societies, with examples and limitations.
Answer outline
Introduction
G. S. Ghurye (1893 to 1983), took his B.A. and M.A. in Sanskrit at Elphinstone College, Bombay, and his PhD at Cambridge (1922) under W. H. R. Rivers, headed the Bombay University sociology department from 1924 until he retired in 1959, and used Sanskrit texts, history and comparative data to study caste, sadhus, costume and tribes.
The approach in Ghurye
- Caste and Race in India (1932) traced caste through texts and history.
- Indian Sadhus (1953) and Vedic India (1979) drew on textual sources.
- He also wrote comparative works such as Race Relations in Negro Africa (1952) and Cities and Civilization (1962).
Use for other societies
- Textual civilisations: Confucian classics for China, the Quran, hadith and fiqh for Islamic societies, and the Bible and canon law for medieval Europe let a sociologist reconstruct norms, legitimations and continuities.
- Max Weber wrote The Religion of China (1915), The Religion of India (1915) and Ancient Judaism (1920) in the context of his economic sociology; Dumont, author of Homo Hierarchicus (1966), contrasted holism with individualism.
- History and long-term change: texts allow study of how institutions such as kinship, law or kingship developed, which fieldwork alone cannot show.
- Understanding the actors' own categories (a society's own terms) avoids imposing outside concepts.
Limitations
- Book view versus field view: texts may record elite or priestly ideals, not practice.
- Risk of essentialising a society as unchanging and of ignoring oral cultures, women and lower castes or classes.
- Societies without written traditions need ethnography.
Conclusion
Indology is a useful entry point to any literate civilisation if combined with fieldwork and historical criticism.
Examples and data to cite
- Ghurye founded the Indian Sociological Society and its journal Sociological Bulletin.
Facts to remember
- Ghurye's PhD (Cambridge, 1922) was guided by W. H. R. Rivers and completed under A. C. Haddon.
- Louis Dumont and David Pocock founded Contributions to Indian Sociology in 1957.