How does A. R. Desai argue that Indian social classes must be studied through the colonial mode of production? Elucidate.
10 marks · directive: Elucidate
The core of a good answer
For Desai, who took a Marxist and dialectical historical approach, classes arise from the system of production; colonial rule reorganised India's economy (for example by creating a market in land through settlements such as the Permanent Settlement), so the classes of modern India and the bourgeois character of the national movement must be understood through that colonial economic order.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
Elucidate means explain clearly with reasons. Set out Desai's Marxist method, show how colonial economic change produced new classes, and note debates.
Answer outline
Introduction
A. R. Desai (1915 to 1994) obtained his PhD under Ghurye in 1946; Social Background of Indian Nationalism (1948) used a dialectical historical approach.
Method
- Social structure is shaped by the mode of production; to study classes one must study property relations and the economy.
- Colonialism subordinated India's economy to British capitalism.
New classes from colonial production
- Land settlements (the Permanent Settlement of 1793, and the ryotwari and mahalwari systems) changed land rights; the Permanent Settlement gave proprietary rights to landholders and revenue intermediaries and created a land market, while the Bengal peasantry grew poorer.
- Commercialisation of agriculture: in Bengal, landlords pushed tenants into plantation-style farming of cash crops.
- English education aimed, in Macaulay's words, at 'a class of persons, Indian in blood and colour, but English in taste'; Desai traced the national movement's bourgeois class character.
Implications and debates
- Desai examined the bourgeois class character and inner contradictions of the national movement, and later wrote State and Society in India: Essays in Dissent (1975).
Conclusion
Desai's approach links class formation to colonial capitalism and remains a key alternative to caste-centred or textual views.
Examples and data to cite
- Desai's Rural Sociology in India (1959) and Agrarian Struggles in India after Independence (1986) applied the same approach.
Facts to remember
- Desai took his PhD under G. S. Ghurye (1946) but analysed Indian society in Marxist terms.
- Permanent Settlement in Bengal: 1793, under Lord Cornwallis.