Compare G. S. Ghurye’s and A. R. Desai’s approaches used in understanding Indian society.
10 marks · directive: Compare
The core of a good answer
Ghurye and Desai, teacher and student at Bombay, differed fundamentally: Ghurye used an Indological, historical and diffusionist approach that saw Indian society as a continuous Hindu civilisation shaped by caste and culture, while Desai used a Marxist, historical-materialist approach that explained Indian society through the mode of production, classes and colonial capitalism.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
A comparison needs points of similarity and contrast on method, unit of analysis, view of change and political orientation, with their main works.
Answer outline
Introduction
Ghurye (1893 to 1983) headed the Bombay department from 1924 to 1959; Desai (1915 to 1994) completed his PhD under him in 1946.
Similarities
- Both used history to understand the present and wrote on a wide canvas (caste, tribes, nationalism, urbanisation).
Differences
- Method: Ghurye used Sanskrit texts, history and comparison (Caste and Race in India, 1932); Desai used a Marxist, dialectical historical approach (Social Background of Indian Nationalism, 1948).
- Key unit: Ghurye focused on caste, religion and culture; Desai on class, property and economy.
- Change: Ghurye stressed cultural continuity and integration; Desai saw contradiction and conflict driving change.
- On the State: Ghurye was concerned with national unity and cultural integration; Desai wrote critically on the post-colonial State (State and Society in India: Essays in Dissent, 1975).
- Sources: texts and records versus economic data and movements (Agrarian Struggles in India after Independence, 1986).
Assessment
- Ghurye's approach risks Brahmanical bias and textual idealism; Desai's risks economic reductionism and neglect of caste and culture.
Conclusion
Together they represent two founding streams of Indian sociology: the cultural-Indological and the Marxist-historical.
Examples and data to cite
- Ghurye wrote The Aborigines, 'So-called', and Their Future (1943) on the place of tribes.
Facts to remember
- Desai's PhD was supervised by Ghurye (1946).
- Ghurye founded the Indian Sociological Society and Sociological Bulletin.